An analysis of recall and recognition skills as a function of retrieval and storage limitations in retarded Down's and normal subjects
This investigation compared the performance of retarded Down's subjects with two control groups on a battery of six short-term memory tests for the purpose of determining whether the limitations in memory skills were due to a deficit in the storage or retrieval of information. The control groups were composed of normal subjects matched with the experimental group on the basis of mental age (MA Controls) and chronological age (CA Controls). Test stimuli consisted of 24 one-syllable nouns chosen from the early frames of the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test. All subjects possessed a receptive and expressive understanding for these words. Six word lists, composed of unrelated word sequences ranging in length from two to eight items, were created. Recall abilities for these sequences were assessed utilizing the same procedures as the digit span subtest of the W.I.S.C. (Wechsler, 1949). Recognition testing was conducted through the use of a three-alternative forced-choice picture discrimination task. Stimuli were presented either visually (in pictoral form) or auditorily at the rate of one word per second. Subjects' responses on the recognition tests were either verbal or nonverbal (pointing). Each subject was tested individually in one session. The order of test presentation, as well as selection of word lists to be used for each test, was randomized.
Statistical analysis of test data was conducted through the use of a three-factor mixed design with repeated measures on two factors. A significant three-way interaction (p < .05) precluded testing for main effects. Post hoc comparisons for simple effects wereconducted utilizing the Duncan's Multiple Range Test. These analyses yielded the following results:
1. The auditory recall abilities of Down's subjects were extremely limited when compared with the performance of normal subjects of comparable mental ages.
2. The memory skills of Down's subjects were greatest on auditory recognition tests, where their performance was indistinguishable from normal subjects of comparable mental ages. This suggests that at least part of the reason for the Down's poor auditory recall is that they have access to only a small portion of the items that they are able to store (i.e. they have a retrieval deficit).
3. The scores of the Down's subjects on auditory recognition tests were not sufficiently high to suggest that their storage skills are unimpaired. When compared with normal subjects of comparable chronological ages, it appears that these subjects may possess a storage deficit in addition to the retrieval deficit.
4. There was no significant difference between the visual recall and visual recognition scores of the Down's subjects, suggesting that their ability to store visual images is greatly impaired (much more so than for auditorily presented stimuli).
5. The addition of a verbal encoding task during recognition testing did not have a significant effect upon the memory skills of any of the subject groups in this investigation.
6. The MA controls in this investigation (i.e. normal subjects between the ages of 3 1/2 and 5 1/2 years) had poorer visual recall than auditory recall skills. The effect which the type of sensory input had on these subjects became nonsignificant when recognition tests were utilized. This suggests that, at these ages, normal children are less adept at retrieving visually presented stimuli.
Thesis76b.M223.pdf
4.12 MB
Adobe PDF
85216747cd2bda71d5d039028180a74f