American wage arbitration, 1950-74
The purpose of this study was to provide managers and unions with information concerning the use of wage arbitration as an alternative to the strike. As criticisms of wage arbitration might be based on outdated or erroneous information, a reevaluation of the process was in order.
The cornerstone of published knowledge about wage arbitration is Irving Bernstein's The Arbitration of Wages. This study follows Bernstein's case study approach. The period of analysis extends from the end of Bernstein's study in mid-year 1950 through the end of 1974. Two primary sources of case data were used: The Bureau of National Affairs' Labor Arbitration Reports and Commerce Clearing House's Labor Arbitration Awards.
The study questions several common myths concerning wage arbitration. First, the myth that wage arbitration tends to destroy collective bargaining is unsubstantiated by the reported cases. Evidence of repeated use by particular firms and unions was not found, so there is no proof of a narcotic effect.
Second, it is frequently stated that the declining number of reported wage arbitrations is evidence of the failure of the process. The study finds no clear evidence concerning the number of wage arbitrations, most of which go unreported, and argues that such a statistic is not an appropriate measurement of success in any event.
Third, it is often argued that wage arbitration is too radical and risky. Examination of the cases indicates a consistent arbitral application of the same criteria introduced in collective bargaining. There was a slight preference for the employers' positions and intra-industry wage comparisons were the most frequently applied standards. Application of the intra-industry comparison criterion generally leads to maintenance of relative wage rates among firms within an industry over time.
The fourth myth proposes that the parties have such a great fear of wage arbitration that they will generally turn to a tripartite board when utilizing it. Contrary to this myth, it was shown that all-neutral panels were the overwhelming (71.8 percent of the cases) favorites of the parties.
The last myth is that arbitrators split the difference between the parties. Only five cases were found where the arbitrators either consciously or unconsciously split the difference.
Recent events such as the signing of the "Experimental Negotiating Agreement" in the basic steel industry, the arbitration of professional baseball players' salaries, and the wage arbitration clause in the most recent contract (1976) between National Airlines and the Air Line Employees Association indicate a role of growing importance for wage arbitration in the United States.
Thesis76b.H257.pdf
6.03 MB
Adobe PDF
08f0cd8bbfb872728533fba0fa4b8e5e