The measurement of factors of satisfaction and dissatisfaction which affect Tennessee teachers in their work
This study was concerned with: (1) measuring and evaluating the factors leading to satisfaction and dissatisfaction among elementary and secondary school teachers in the State of Tennessee, and (2) identifying possible sources of variance in satisfaction and dissatisfaction.
The theoretical base for the study was the Herzberg et al. two-factor Hygiene-Motivator theory.
A random sample of 642 teachers, of grades 1-12, was selected from the entire school teacher population of the State. Each school district was represented by a proportionate sample.
The main thrust of the study was to determine if there were important differences in factors leading to satisfaction from those factors leading to dissatisfaction. Also, investigated were the effects of: (1) age, (2) experience, (3) sex, (4) race, (5) education, (6) grade taught, (7) type school (rural vs urban), (8) marital status, (9) income dependency, and (10) region of the State.
The Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ) was used to gather data from the teachers. There was a 64 percent response to this questionnaire. The data were analyzed by comparing average responses to factors first through F tests, then the variables were subjected to one-way analyses of variance for each factor.
The major findings of this study were:
1. Teachers showed an important difference in satisfaction between intrinsic and extrinsic factors, showing a higher level of satisfaction with intrinsic factors. Also comparisons with the MSQ "norm" group showed Tennessee teachers registered a significantly lower satisfaction for almost all intrinsic factors and all extrinsic factors with extrinsic factors having the greatest deviations from the "norm" group.
2. Older and more experienced teachers showed a greater satisfaction on all factors than younger and less experienced teachers. Nine of the differences were statistically significant at the 95 percent confidence.
3. There was no observed effect of race.
4. Teachers with a secondary source of income showed greater satisfaction with Compensation and Advancement.
5. Married teachers showed a greater degree of general satisfaction than single teachers.
6. There was little difference by sex except female teachers showed greater satisfaction with Compensation and Company Policies and Practices.
7. Elementary school teachers showed greater satisfaction with Advancement and Company Policies and Practices than secondary school teachers.
8. Teachers from rural schools showed greater satisfaction with the factors of Social Status and Activity than teachers from urban schools.
9. Teachers with a Master's degree plus 45 hours or more showed greater satisfaction for all but two factors; however, the sample size of these teachers was too small for statistical significance.
10. Teachers from East Tennessee showed higher satisfaction with factors of social service, creativity, achievement, co-workers and activity than teachers from Middle or West Tennessee.
The major conclusion from this study was that Tennessee teachers indicated a higher satisfaction level from all intrinsic factors of teaching than they did for all extrinsic factors.
Thesis76b.H244.pdf
7.37 MB
Adobe PDF
e33a6a615b0738174f1596687a98fda3