The philosophes and the right to revolutionary action
This dissertation examines the thought and opinion of the French philosophes relevant to the question of the right to revolutionary action. The dissertation encompasses the thought and opinion of Montesquieu and Rousseau, the two seminal political philosophers of the French Enlightenment, and Diderot and Voltaire, whose influence and reputations among their contemporaries were unsurpassed.
In recognition of John Locke's pervasive influence on the political thought of the French Enlightenment, Chapter I offers a discussion of Locke's theory of revolutionary action. Locke's theory serves as a point of comparison and reference in Chapters II through V, pertaining to individual analyses of the philosophes and the right to revolutionary action. Chapter VI offers a comparative analysis of the philosophes' respective theories and attempts to ascertain whether the philosophes restricted their view of the right to revolution to only a theoretical ideal, or whether they also considered revolutionary action as a justified practical alternative, although admittedly extreme, for the political and social reconstruction of a nation ruled by an intransigent tyrant.
The dissertation concludes that Voltaire, as a pragmatic reformer who often expressed a disdain for theoretical speculation, never considered or developed a theoretical justification for revolution. In the practical dimension, Voltaire was unequivocal in his condemnation of any form of revolutionary action. Montesquieu and Rousseau affirmed a general theoretical right to revolution, but that affirmation remained a theoretical ideal. In terms of practical applicability, both Montesquieu and Rousseau were compatible with Voltaire in refusing to condone or endorse revolutionary action. Only Diderot, with his explicit and persistent affirmations of the right to revolutionary action, viewed revolution as a justified and practical alternative to a tyrant's rule.
Thesis76b.C322.pdf
7.27 MB
Adobe PDF
d8363c41c7e3530fea5f701ba53f0fec