The comparison of the performance and achievement value of work, volunteer, and homemaking behaviors of supervisory male and female employees, non-supervisory female employees, and female volunteer workers
The purpose of this study was to assess and compare the reported frequency of performance and achievement value of work, volunteer, and homemaking behaviors of supervisory male and female employees, nonsupervisory female employees, and female volunteer workers. Subjects were 47 male supervisory employees in high status occupations, 80 female supervisory employees in high status occupations, 65 female non-supervisory employees, and 39 female members of women's civic organizations (female volunteer workers).
Two instruments were developed: (1) Activity Questionnaire to assess the frequency of performance of 57 behaviors within the domains of home, volunteer activity, and paid employment (19 per activity domain); and (2) Achievement Behavior Checklist - to determine how important the same 57 behaviors would be for a high achieving person to perform. . Three hypotheses based on previous research concerning the need for achievement and role conflict were tested to investigate differences among the groups in frequency of performance and the achievement values associated with the behaviors studied.
Support was established for the hypothesis that no differences would exist between the employment related behaviors of supervisory men and women, but that both groups would report a greater frequency of such behaviors than non-supervisory women. Also, as predicted, the supervisory men reported performing fewer non-children related home behaviors than the supervisory female group. However, no differences were found among the groups on the performance of volunteer type behaviors.
The prediction that there would be no differences between the achievement values assigned to the home, volunteer, and paid employment behaviors by the groups received strong but not full support because the supervisory females valued work significantly higher than the other groups. Further, the prediction that all groups would rate work as most important, volunteer next, and home last was supported by the findings for all groups except the non-supervisory females who rated work as the most important, home as the next in importance, and volunteer least.
The reported frequency of performance differed significantly from the values assigned to these behaviors for the supervisory and nonsupervisory females and the female volunteer workers. As expected from the literature on ambivalence, the female groups reported performing home, work, and volunteer behaviors at a level significantly different from the value level they assigned to the same behaviors. However, the supervisory men differed significantly between their reported and valued behaviors; this was not expected since the prediction was based on the presumed congruence of male activities with achievement values.
Areas for additional research were discussed. These included a replication of the study with more stringent definitions for group categorization, the development of a more comprehensive and discriminating group of behaviors, and examination of subjects within similar occupations, assessment of management training in role conflict resolution and differences between the achievement values assigned to the female and male supervisors in high status occupations.
Thesis76b.B453.pdf
4.31 MB
Adobe PDF
ad9ba812799302fb37134177dd82546c