The leadership behavior of selected local directors of vocational education in Tennessee
In view of the rapid expansion of vocational education, a great need has been sensed for strong leadership in the local school district. However, the expansion has not allowed adequate time in assessing the leadership behavior of the person who assumes the role of local director of vocational education. Therefore, the purpose of the study was to determine how local directors of vocational education and vocational teachers described the actual and ideal behavior of the local director.
The impetus of the study suggested utilization of the Leader Behavior Description Questionnaire. Developed by Ohio State University, the LBDQ reveals Initiating Structures and Consideration for the leader being described. Consequently, local directors and vocational teachers in 30 Tennessee school systems were asked to describe actual and ideal behavior of local directors. An on-site visit was made to each of the school districts for data collection.
In attempting to analyze the data, three statistical techniques were used. First, the Kendall Coefficient of Concordance was used to determine the amount of agreement among the subordinates in the descriptions they offered of actual and ideal behavior. For the systems showing significant agreement, the Spearman Rank Correlation Coefficient was utilized to measure the association of local directors' responses and vocational teachers' responses. Finally, the Wilcoxon Matched-Pairs Signed-Ranks test was used to draw conclusions about the scores of all 30 school districts.
A number of findings were drawn regarding the actual behavior of the local director of vocational education. Using all 30 systems, a comparison of the subordinates' and local director's actual behavior revealed basic association on both dimensions of the LBDQ. However, local directors rated their actual behavior consistently higher than did their subordinates. Using only those systems in which there was agreement among subordinates in describing the actual behavior of the local director, a comparison of the subordinates' and director's description of actual behavior revealed diverse trends on the LBDQ-Real, Consideration and LBDQ-Real, Initiating Structures. On the Consideration scale, less than half of these systems showed significant association between the subordinates' and local director's scores. On the Initiating Structures scale, a majority of systems showed significant association between subordinates' and local director's scores.
Several findings were also drawn from an analysis of the results of the ideal behavior description on the LBDQ-Ideal. Using all 30 systems, a comparison of the subordinates' and local director's description of ideal behavior revealed basic association on both dimensions of the LBDQ. Using only those systems in which there was agreement among subordinates in describing the ideal behavior of the local director, a comparison of the subordinates' and local director's description of ideal behavior revealed significant association on each dimension. However, only one system appeared in both dimensions.
A comparison of the actual and ideal dimensions of the director's behavior revealed that the ideal local director should possess a higher degree of Consideration and Initiating Structures than the actual director was rated as having. This opinion was held by both local directors and vocational teachers.
These findings led to the formulation of several conclusions. It was concluded that subordinates were realistic in observing the behavior that was exhibited by the local director. The findings reflected that the majority of vocational teachers did not have a clear understanding of how the ideal director should behave. Since ideal behavior was rated consistently higher than actual behavior, it was concluded that local directors evidenced a need to upgrade their job performance. Likewise, Subordinates saw a need for local directors to upgrade their skills by rating ideal behavior higher than actual behavior. The findings indicated that local directors were more effective in accomplishing tasks than in interpersonal skills. Finally, it was concluded that subordinates had not been exposed to a systematic job description; subordinates did not have a consistent, firmly established theoretical model of ideal leader behavior.
As a result of these conclusions, several recommendations were presented. With such confusion about the ideal behavior of the local director of vocational education, it was recommended that a well-defined job description emerge incorporating the ideas of both local directors and vocational teachers. A need for inservice activities was also seen because of the consistently lower ratings on the LBDQ-Real than on the LBDQ-Ideal. In addition, inservice activities could help provide a more realistic view of the role of the local director of vocational education.
Fewer systems showed significant association on the LBDQ-Real, Consideration scale than on the LBDQ-Real, Initiating Structures scale. Therefore, it was recommended that preservice activities by universities include a greater emphasis on group dynamics, communication skills, and interpersonal relations.
A need for more descriptive research in the system showing the greatest amount of association on the various aspects of the LBDq was pointed out. Also, preliminary steps for much needed experimental research were developed. Further research could include the opinions of the local directors' peer group as well as their subordinates. In conclusion, it was recommended that further research on leadership in vocational education include those studies which have concentrated on competencies as well as the behavior of the local director of vocational education.
Thesis76b.A552.pdf
3.39 MB
Adobe PDF
153b0f35de5052093bae4a783d48de4e