Independent schoolwork : a "keystone" behavior for classroom intervention strategies
The intention of this study was to test the effect, in three public school classrooms of the third and fourth grades, of a short, 15-minute period devoted to quiet, independent schoolwork. Based on earlier work the study attempts to find changes in the rates of other behaviors not manipulated directly by the experiment. Furthermore, the study investigates the possibility that behaviors may also be effected at later times in the day by the experimental condition. In an ANOVA reversal design, the study experimented with the 15-minute "Quiet Time" as an addition to a standard contingency management program.
The data for the study was gathered by the teachers who counted the students' work units as they were completed, and the students' rule violations. Also trained observers entered the classroom and observed randomly selected children. The data was analyzed statistically and graphed, and generally showed the significant, immediate changes in behavior could be manipulated by the teacher when they used a quiet period every morning. Any later effects in the day were limited to a short term effect in a single classroom. The results merely show that the children could remain quiet and work independently.
The study concludes with a discussion of the ethical questions raised by behavior change strategies which ask children to remain quiet. In this study the results are equivocal and somewhat inconclusive. The expected overall effect of Quiet Time was not achieved, however, the population in this study was normalized and heterogeneous. It is perhaps true that the response set stability described in the literature of deviant behavior is limited to deviant populations; the findings of this study do not challenge those notions. Quiet Time, or independent behavior, may have much greater effects on the behaviors of troublesome children rather than the behaviors of normal populations.
Thesis76b.C633.pdf
1.29 MB
Adobe PDF
8ea0face952fa4ad99eab2c70038a0de