A comparison of workbook-centered versus independent study-centered vocabulary learning
Vocabulary instruction is an important part of the high school English curriculum. Traditionally, the teacher presents the students with the vocabulary study words they must master. Taking into consideration the various vocabulary achievement levels of the students within one English class, it is likely that some students will have mastered some of the study words already, while others are far behind in vocabulary development. This study was designed to compare a traditional method of vocabulary instruction, in this case, a workbook approach, to an individualized approach in which the students generate their own study words.
The null hypothesis for this study stated that there would be no significant difference in average rate of retention of two groups of vocabulary words among high, average, and low achievers or between males and females. Data for the study were gathered from four Vocabulary Building classes at West High School, Knoxville, Tennessee, during the third quarter of the school year, 1976. Two teachers each taught one workbook approach and one individualized approach class. A total of 84 students were the sample from which the data analysis was made. The same material was presented in all four classes except for the 150 vocabulary study words. The final examination, for which the students had to use 25 of their vocabulary study words in written sentences that that reflected their correct meaning and part of speech, served as the pretest. Eight weeks later the students repeated their final examinations. The two sets of tests were graded by five experienced, impartial English teachers.
The mean rate of retention between the pre- and posttests was subjected to statistical analysis. The results showed that there were no significant differences in the retention rates among the three achievement levels. Analysis also showed that males retained significantly more than females. Therefore the first part of the null hypothesis was accepted and the second part was rejected.
Thesis76.S2594.pdf
4 MB
Adobe PDF
14633881057b192a9925520e7cfedf4f