Technical, price, and economic efficiency measures in the Tennessee meat packing and processing industry
The purpose of this study was (1) to determine the changes that have occurred in expenditures for energy sources, petrochemical based materials, and related items used in the Tennessee meat packing and processing industry between 1974 and 1975, (2) to determine the effect of these changes on relative costs, efficiencies, and operating procedures and programs, and (3) to determine if a significant change occurred in the minimum average cost of production between 1974 and 1975.
Price-quantity data for 40 packer level units were obtained with an industry questionnaire. Variables selected for analysis included physical amounts and expenditures for hired labor, electricity, water and sewage service, natural gas, and supplies and cleaning materials. These five inputs were hypothesized to be key factors in estimating the efficiency of production in the meat packing and processing industry.
The Farrell efficiency model was used to estimate technical, price, and economic efficiency measures for the slaughterers under study in 1974 and 1975. Input-output ratios for the operating units were analyzed as the linear programming algorithm iterated through the 40 linear programming problems.
Two analyses were used in the study. The first, a composite analysis, assumed that no differences existed in the scale and production characteristics of custom and commercial slaughterers. Efficiency measures were found for the 40 observations in an algorithm containing input-output ratios of both custom and commercial slaughterers. A second analysis classified custom and commercial slaughterers into two subsamples based on the type of license held by the firm. Technical, price, and economic efficiency ratings were found for each observation relative to other slaughterers within the same slaughtering classification.
Technical and price efficiency ratings were found for each observation in the sample, relative to a postulated standard of perfect efficiency set forth by the efficient unit isoquant (EUI). Observations with a maximum objective function value equal to one, formed the convex closure of the EUI. As such, they demonstrated the "best" performance of the sampled observations in their adjustments to factor proportions and factor prices.
Economic efficiency for the 40 observations were formed as the product of their respective technical and price efficiency ratings, found with the linear programming algorithms. This measure was equivalent to the inverse ratio of average cost of production. A firm that was perfectly efficient, both technically and with respect to factor prices, also was 100 percent economically efficient. Such a firm could be assumed to have the minimum average costs of production of the sampled observations, with respect to the five inputs included in the analysis.
Results of the Mann-Whitney statistical test indicated that a significant increase occurred in the average cost of production for commercial slaughterers between 1974 and 1975.
The Kruskal-Wallis rank-sum test indicated that a significant difference existed in the average cost of production for custom and commercial slaughterers in 1975. The lower average cost of production for custom slaughterers suggested that these slaughterers as a group were able to respond more readily to increased costs for inputs to production.
Thesis76.P349.pdf
3.8 MB
Adobe PDF
1a213aef560d504a2bf4490fbe5b62df