A field application of inoculation theory
Inoculation theory has drawn the attention of many researchers since 1960 when it was popularized by William J. McGuire. Experimenters, including McGuire, have tested scores of variables in replicating and extending inoculation principles but generally in a sterile laboratory environment.
The main purpose of this investigation was to test basic principles of inoculation theory in a situation outside of the laboratory. Specifically, the principles of inoculation theory were applied to reduce the negative response and maintain positive attitudes toward the TV format of Public Speaking 2311 at The University of Tennessee, Knoxville. From previous experience, it had been found that students enrolled in the TV sections were prone to develop negative attitudes toward the television aspect of teaching 2311. It was theorized that a forewarning message about the Tv format and about criticisms to which students would probably be exposed could help maintain positive and reduce negative attitudes.
A pretest measuring student attitudes toward the Tv format of Public Speaking 23ll was given to 14 of the 16 TV sections in the first five minutes of the first class meeting in the Spring term l976. Four weeks later all 14 sections plus two additional ones completed a comparable posttest. The 14 sections were randomly divided into two treatment groups: (1) Group A, consisting of three sections of public speaking, immediately after the pretest received an inoculative two-sided oral presentation which emphasized advantages, but discussed TV format criticisms; and (2) Group B consisting of three sections of public speaking, immediately after the pretest received a supportive one-sided oral treatment which discussed Tv format advantages only. Group C, consisting of eight public speaking sections, served as a control group and received no message between the pretest and posttest. An additional two sections of public speaking classes, Group D, received no message or pretest, but did complete a posttest. Group D served as a second control group to determine the effects of pretesting. An attempt was made to reinforce the effects of the two main treatment groups by presenting an additional booster message to one public speaking section in each of the A and B treatment groups midway between the pretest and the posttest.
It was assumed that students in all groups would be exposed to critical remarks concerning the Tv format during the four week period between the pretest and posttest and a test item was added to the posttest to confirm this assumption.
In analyzing the results, students were broken into groups according to their initial attitude toward the course and a 3 x 3 analysis of variance was used to test the effects of the initial attitude (positive, neutral, or negative) and type of resistance message heard (two-sided, one-sided, none) on attitude change toward the TV format of teaching Public Speaking.
The general hypothesis stated that the principles of inoculation theory could be successfully applied to predict attitude change in this field experiment. Two specific experimental hypotheses stated that: (1) the inoculative two-sided treatment would prove superior to the supportive one-sided message in (a) maintaining positive attitudes and (b) shifting initially neutral and negative attitudes toward a more positive position in regard to the TV format; (2) students hearing either message (supportive or inoculative) would be more likely than the students hearing no resistance message to (a) maintain positive attitudes or (b) shift initially neutral or negative attitudes toward a more positive position in regard to the TV format; (3) Group D (no pretest or message) would have less positive attitudes toward the TV format than Group C, the control group receiving the pretest; and (4) the two sections receiving the booster message would show the most attitude change or reinforcement in the predicted direction.
The main effect of the hypothetical superiority of the inoculative message over the supportive message was not supported. The messages did affect a change in attitudes as predicted, but in the opposite direction. Using a controversial issue in the field experiment, the one-sided supportive message proved superior to the two-sided inoculation treatment in all respects. The booster message as predicted did accentuate trends, though not significantly, but again opposite to the predicted direction. Group D, the non-message, non-pretest group, did not display more hostility toward the Tv format as hypothesized. Hypothesis II as stated was supported.
Thesis76.W552.pdf
3.35 MB
Adobe PDF
aed03190c7d9903928e17ad9461036fd