An analysis of the strategic and operational planning systems in large United States banks
The purpose of this research was to investigate the nature and effectiveness of formal planning in large U.S. banks. The study focused on the utilization of profit planning in large U.S. banks, the evolution and state of development of strategic long-range corporate planning by the largest U.S. banks, the identification of the type of strategic long-range corporate planning system that seemed to be evolving as the most effective for large U.S. banks, and the quantification of the relationship between the comprehensiveness of formal planning and financial performance in selected large U.S. banks.
The sample population for the first phase of this study was the fifty largest banks in the following ten states: Alabama, Georgia, Pennsylvania, New York, North Carolina, Maryland, Illinois, Massachusetts, Virginia, and Tennessee. Mostly Eastern banks were selected because of their geographical proximity which made interviews possible within the limits of time and resources. Initially, a personal letter of inquiry on planning activities was sent to the presidents of the fifty banks and officers in twenty-nine of the fifty banks responded. Subsequently personal "depth interviews" were held with executives or planning specialists in seventeen of the responding banks. Upon completion of each interview, the interviewee was asked to rate his bank's comprehensiveness of planning by means of a quick-answer questionnaire. The responses were analyzed according to the Guttman Scalogram-Analysis procedure and six of eighteen questions were identified which formed a cumulative planning scale. Later a revised three-page questionnaire was constructed around the six questions and it was mailed to the 150 largest domestic, non-related, non-special purpose banks in the 48 contiguous states and the District of Columbia. Officers in 92 of the 150 banks (61%) completed the questionnaire and the data generated were used to supplement that which had been previously collected and to subdivide the banks into categories in order to test the hypothesis that large U.S. banks with more comprehensive planning financially outperform large U.S. banks with less comprehensive planning.
The study indicated that in 1976 "profit planning" was receiving an unusual amount of attention within the banking industry because of a general earnings decline which had started for many banks in late 1974. The questionnaire results showed that only 37% of the sampled banks had profit planning systems in 1966 but that by the middle of 1976 the figure had risen to 99%. Bank "profit planning" information obtained in the interviews on implementation, design, and semantic problems were reported and discussed.
This study also indicated that there was considerable interest in formal strategic long-range corporate planning among the large U.S. bankers. The questionnaire responses revealed that 73% of the sampled banks had started strategic planning systems by September 1, 1976, but that only 9% of the banks had systems which were over ten years old. The depth interview data indicated that the percentage of large U.S. banks with fully developed and operational strategic planning systems was probably closer to 20% than it was to 73%. Information on the organization for strategic bank planning and the administrative procedures being utilized were presented and discussed. A strategic planning system that seemed to be evolving as the most effective for large U.S. banks was described and analyzed by means of a case study.
This study focused on the effectiveness of formal large U.S. bank planning by quantifying the relationship between comprehensiveness of planning and financial performance in selected institutions. Analyses were conducted using a cumulative planning scale, two averaging methods, two control groups, three measures of financial performance, the student "t" distribution, and four different groupings of the sampled banks. The result offered some support for the study hypothesis when the measures of financial performance were either changes in net income or return on owners' investment and almost no support when the measure was return on total assets.
The study led to the conclusion that formal planning in the form of profit planning and strategic planning is increasingly being integrated into the management systems of large U.S. banks. Finally the results of this study suggest that future research into the effectiveness of formal planning is warranted.
Thesis77b.W568.pdf
12.14 MB
Adobe PDF
735d1820769115f89f0a6e65fd5d68fa