The role of business and industry in vocational education in the public secondary schools in Tennessee
Purpose
The primary purpose of the study was to determine business and industry involvement in public secondary vocational education in Tennessee by analyzing and comparing the present and desired involvement by business and industry, and the facilitating and restricting factors, as perceived by school administrators, vocational educators, and business and industry personnel. Specifically, the study attempted to determine: (1) business and industry involvement that presently exists in public secondary vocational education in Tennessee; (2) business and industry involvement that should exist in public secondary vocational education in Tennessee; and (3) factors which facilitate or restrict business and industry involvement in public secondary vocational education in Tennessee.
Method
The study included 421 individuals comprising reference groups of school administrators (school superintendents and high school principals); vocational educators (vocational directors and vocational instructors); and business and industry personnel (managers, supervisors or foremen, and skilled employees). A stratified random sample comprised of 20 of the 95 counties in Tennessee was selected. Within each county selected, 100 percent of the school superintendents, high school principals and vocational directors were utilized. Four vocational instructors and four business and industry concerns were also selected from each of those counties to participate in the study.
Validated questionnaires were located and submitted to a panel of experts for further validation. The instruments were then tested in a school system not included in the sample population. All data were collected by mail responses.
Data gathered for this study were grouped and analyzed through the use of a special computer package entitled Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS). Differences between reference groups' opinions were tested using contingency tables and the Chi Square statistic. The results were used in conjunction with opinion percentages to determine: (1) levels and adequacy of business and industry involvement, (2) methods of business and industry involvement, and (3) facilitating and restricting factors to business and industry involvement.
Findings. Analyses and interpretations of data indicated the following findings:
1. There was no general consensus on any service for both present and desired involvement.
2. There was a general consensus on only 2 of the 42 services listed for present involvement; 1 no involvement and 1 some involvement.
3. There was a general consensus on only 8 of the 42 services listed for desired involvement; 7 some involvement and 1 in a great deal of involvement.
4. There was a consensus on 41 of the 42 services listed for present involvement between school administrators and vocational educators.
5. There was a consensus on all 42 services listed for desired involvement between school administrators and vocational educators.
6. There was a general consensus of desirability expressed for business and industry's participation through part time consultants and student club programs.
7. The extent of agreement concerning the traditional methods of business and industry involvement (advisory committees and cooperative education) was significant below the .Ol level for both methods at both the present and desired levels of involvement.
8. There was no general consensus on any service at both the present and desired levels of involvement, thus indicating a significant inadequacy of involvement.
9. Three facilitating, three restricting and one neutral factor were identified.
10. Fifty-eight percent of the school administrators indicated they had participated in a formal business and industry--vocational education cooperative endeavor, compared to 36 percent of the vocational educators and 24 percent of the business and industry personnel.
11. Ninety-three percent of the vocational educators indicated they had fruitful experiences when they were involved in those cooperative endeavors, compared to 89 percent of the school administrators and 67 percent of the business and industry personnel.
Thesis77b.S368.pdf
8.28 MB
Adobe PDF
f39bd0792e4ccd4fe7c6ba7965be6264