The location of Knoxville's new wastewater treatment facility : a case study of the decision-making and site selection processes and citizen involvement
This study examines the processes involved in selecting a site for Knoxville's proposed wastewater treatment facility. The processes examined were: (1) the decision-making process, (2) the site selection process, and (3) the citizen involvement which occurred in the planning and site selection processes for the wastewater treatment facility. The criteria used in site selection were also examined.
Two methods were employed to gather data for this thesis: (1) a literature review of texts and articles concerning the location of sewage treatment plants, citizen participation, and decision-making; and (2) a case study of the selection of the Cox Sky Ranch as the location for Knoxville's proposed wastewater treatment plant focusing on the three processes previously mentioned. A review of newspaper articles, transcripts of public hearings, the technical studies prepared for Knoxville, and interviews with the principal participants of the processes provided information for the case study.
Knoxville was cited for discharging inadequately treated sewage into Fort Loudoun Lake in late 1971 by the Tennessee Department of Public Health and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. To remedy the problems the city proposed to construct a wastewater treatment facility at the Cox Sky Ranch. This site was recommended by the city's engineers and was accepted by Mayor Kyle Testerman. Residents of the area fearing degradation of their neighborhood sought to have the site changed.
In examining this case study it was found that by selecting the Cox Sky Ranch as the location for the new sewage treatment plant, the city had selected a less than optimum location. The optimum location for a new facility, according to studies prepared by Rykman, Edgerly, Tomlinson, and Associates, was the Jo Anderson Farm owned by the University of Tennessee. The university was unwilling to sell the land to the city and the city was unable to obtain it through the use of eminent domain. It was also found that Mayor Kyle Testerman based his decision to select the Cox Sky Ranch on the technical recommendations of the engineers.
Thesis76.B775.pdf
9.81 MB
Adobe PDF
90f5e17ddacbd4a4596016a3e0c8d91f