The progress of research in organizational development
This study is addressed to the question in which ways the acquisition of knowledge about organizational change and development can be facilitated. It is argued that, although industrial psychologists have often claimed the field of organizational change, they have not engaged in much empirical investigation on the topic. It is suggested that one of the reasons why this is so may reside in the incompatibility of the characteristics of organizational change with the scientific experimental method.
A short review of literature about developments in the philosophy of science was conducted (since some of the problems with the experimental method may be understood better by re-examining the philosophical underpinnings of this method). The purpose of the empirical study was to investigate some of the revisions in the experimental method proposed in recent literature, to increase the validity of data gathered during the research process. It was hypothesized that utilization of techniques of trustbuilding, some degree of experimenter self-disclosure, and participation in instrument design will affect the perception of the research such that it will be perceived as more useful, relevant, valid, clear, and satisfying. These hypotheses were tested in a field experiment which was combined with a survey feedback in order to approximate organizational change conditions. The 29 subjects in the study were all psychiatric technicians employed in a large psychiatric institute in Eastern Tennessee
The experimental group (n = 13) received a treatment which consisted of an oral explanation about the survey feedback and an opportunity to change and comment on the design of the survey. Both experimental and control group received the survey and an evaluation form (the depender variable) about the survey. On the basis of the results obtained in this study, one cannot say that presence of prior knowledge of research and participation in instrument design yields perceptions of increased relevance, validity, clarity, involvement, or satisfaction with that instrument. Alternative explanations were suggested.
Some of the difficulties related to an evaluation of the experimental method by the experimental method were discussed.
Thesis76.B763.pdf
6.61 MB
Adobe PDF
2ce3704a2eb1300c1141e4b5957c21fa