Relationship maintenance in ridesharing groups
The objective of this study was to determine why some ridesharing members continue their group participation while others do not. The dependent variable, relationship maintenance, is one of great concern and familiarity to sociologists. Though the variable is familiar, the group context is not. In the latter sense, this study is of an exploratory nature. In three other ways it is somewhat exceptional. The measurement of relationship maintenance is behavioral even .though taken from the cohesion literature. Equity theory is used to extract three of the independent variables. The design deals with naturally occurring groups rather than experimental groups.
The data were collected from interviews with sixty subjects. Thirty were participating carpool and vanpool members. The other half were dropouts from one of the two pooling types. Ninety percent of the purposive sample worked for two large employers located in the Knoxville, Tennessee standard metropolitan statistical area. The remaining 10 percent were employed by two small companies in the same area.
Four categories of independent variables were introduced. These categories were: (1) traditional, (2) cohesion, (3) TOD constraints, and (4) equity theory. The first two categories have a history of sociological investigation but the latter two do not. Eleven variables, derived from a review of past research in the four categories, were hypothesized to distinguish between participants and dropouts.
Multiple Discriminant Analysis (MDA) was used to evaluate the hypotheses. Of the eleven variables, five were chosen by MDA as having an optimal amount of discriminating power. The five were (1) group satisfaction, (2) TOD constraints, (3) number of agreements, (4) group heterogeneity, :and (5) equity norms. After considering the relationship direction, four hypotheses were judged to be supported. The hypothesis involving heterogeneity was rejected because the relationship direction was inappropriate. Six others were judged unsupported when the independent .variables were rejected by MDA. Of the supported hypotheses, none were traditional group structure or demographic variables, one was a cohesion variable, one was a TOD constraint variable and two were equity theory variables. Equity theory, TOD constraints and cohesion variables explain relationship maintenance for this sample. Group structure and demographic variables proved to be of little value. The results call for further research since the sample was limited. The strength of relationships found testifies to the potential explanatory power of the equity theory perspective in naturally occurring groups.
Thesis77b.O949.pdf
5.96 MB
Adobe PDF
ee214a737345d567060954a5443f4480