Comparison of two measures of assertiveness and the modification of non-assertive behaviors
In gathering normative data for the RAS and CSES, the two scales. were administered to 366 male: and 570 female undergraduate students at the University of Tennessee. Forty of the males who scored at least one standard deviation below the mean were later assigned to either a videotaped modeling, a practice control, a bibliotherapy, or a positive thinking control group in an attempt to assess the effectiveness of these techniques in increasing an individual's level of positive assertion.
Results of the normative data indicated a very high positive correlation between the RAS and CSES (r = .85). There was a significant main effect for age on the CSES and, on the RAS, a significant main effect for sex and age and a significant Sex X Age X Marital Status interaction. Results were discussed in terms of sex, age, and marital status differences and also in terms of differences between the two scales when these previously mentioned factors were considered. Results also indicated that an individual's total RAS or CSES score or his score on items that measured his ability to respond with positive assertion in situations requiring such responses were poor predictors of his actual ability to perform in realistic situations. His assessment of his overall level of assertiveness relative to others was the best predictor of his performance in such situations.
Results of Experiment II indicated that, overall, all treatment techniques were effective in significantly increasing Ss' level of positive assertion from pretest to posttest. When the posttest videotaped ratings of the treatment groups were compared with that of the control group, the expected trend among the groups was observed with the videotaped modeling group being relatively more effective than the practice control and bibliotherapy groups, and the practice control group being relatively more effective than the bibliotherapy group. All groups were relatively more assertive than the positive thinking control group. Statistically, the videotaped modeling and practice control groups were significantly more assertive at posttest than the control group, and the mean level of assertiveness for the three treatment groups was significantly higher than that of the control group. An analysis of the RAS scores did not indicate any significant difference between pretest, posttest, and follow-up scores although the expected trend was observed. On the CSES, however, a significant increase in level of assertiveness from pretest to follow-up was evident.
Possible reasons for discrepancies in results were postulated and suggestions for future research were made.
Thesis77b.N382.pdf
4.71 MB
Adobe PDF
b90cf48fe05b59e578de95ba24040736