Effects of two calculus treatments upon achievement and critical thinking ability
The purpose of this study was to determine if two contrasting treatments of differential calculus have different effects on the students' achievement or critical thinking ability. One of the two treatments contained a rigorous development of the course content, which deemphasized applications and stressed the logical structure of the material: a 'proof" treatment. The other stressed applications and deemphasized the logical structure of the material: a 'nonproof" treatment.
The experiment was conducted at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, with a sample drawn from the Math 1840 (first quarter freshman differential calculus) students enrolled during the Fall quarter, 1976. Two sections were selected for the experiment, one of which was given a "proof" treatment and the other a "nonproof" treatment. The total sample was composed of 67 subjects.
Two major instruments were utilized to investigate the experimental hypotheses: (1) the Comprehensive Final Examination (CFE) and, (2) the Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal (WGCTA). The CFE, which was constructed by the experimenter, consisted of twenty-seven multiple choice questions and five completion questions. At the end of the treatment period, skills achieved in the course were measured for the two treatment groups by the use of the CFE. Two days after the administration of the CFE, twelve selected students were interviewed (six students from each treatment group) to compare their competence in solving selected calculus problems from the CFE. Three problems were chosen from the CFE for the clinical interviews, since they were new problem-solving situations and were neither computational nor theoretical. Pre- and posttest measures on critical thinking ability were collected from both the "proof" and "nonproof" groups by the use of the Watson- Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal (WGCTA), Forms Ym and Zm.
The statistical methods of analysis of variance and covariance were used to compare the two groups with respect to achievement as measured by the CFE and critical thinking ability as measured by the WGCTA posttest. Pretest measures of critical thinking ability (WGCTA, Form Ym) and the ACT mathematics scores were used as covariates. A level of significance of .05 was used in these analyses.
The results of the critical thinking data gathered following the instruction indicated that students of the nonproof" treatment performed significantly better than the students in the 'proof" treatment. Furthermore, the "nonproof" treatment had a significant effect in the improvement of the subjects' critical thinking ability. However, since the statistical power of the tests was low, the hypothesis that there is no significant difference in pre- and posttest mean WGCTA scores for the "proof' treatment was neither rejected nor accepted. The results of the achievement data gathered indicated that the two treatments did not play a significant role in the improvement of skills as measured by the CFE. However, since the statistical power of the test was low, the null hypothesis related to achievement was neither rejected nor accepted.
The combined results of the analysis of the problems in the clinical interviews indicated a higher conceptual understanding on the part of the selected students enrolled in the "nonproof" treatment. Review of the overall responses indicated that 50 percent of the students in the "proof" group and 17 percent in the "nonproof" group required extensive instruction to complete the task. Whereas, 50 percent of the students in the "nonproof" group and 17 percent of the students in the "proof" group exhibited clear understanding of the problems.
Thesis77b.M372.pdf
5 MB
Adobe PDF
154060e9885fab2063b504f7d6f6cb1f