Naturalistic assessment of child smiling and laughing in the first grade classroom : a social perspective
Despite much recent investigation of smiling and laughing behaviors in young children, there has been relatively little attention paid to the social aspects of these behaviors in the classroom environment of school children. The present study was a naturalistic assessment of the relationship of child smiling and laughing behaviors in the classroom to social interactions and social context. Subjects were twenty first grade children and two first grade teachers located in separate classrooms. Children were observed for a total of sixty hours using a precoded category system assessing smiling, laughing and social interaction behaviors and the settings in which they occurred. Observations were conducted on a time-sampling interval basis.
Results showed a striking social component to smiling and laughing in the classroom. Ninety-six percent of all smiling and 99% of all laughing was coded as occurring in a social (versus a nonsocial) context. Strong correlations between frequency of child smiling and frequency of child-child interactions suggested that children who smiled frequently tended to have more frequent interactions with peers than did children who smiled less frequently. Smiling between children appeared to be interdependent, with 50 to 70% of observed child smiling to peers accompanied by smiling from peers. This last finding was qualified by poor inter-rater reliability. There was no apparent relationship between frequency of child smiling and frequency of teacher-child interactions; teacher-child interactions, in fact, appeared to occur as a function of spatial proximity and academic work. Investigation of teacher-child interdependence of smiling was inconclusive. Children smiled to peers considerably more often than to teachers, even when base rates of peer-child and teacher-child interactions were taken into account.
Classroom settings clearly influenced rates of child smiling and social interactions. Play activities and teacher absence from the room clearly facilitated child smiling and peer interactions, while academic tasks inhibited rate of smiling, and watching television most strongly inhibited rate of smiling and rate of interaction with peers. The obvious impact of within-classroom settings upon the behaviors of school children suggested that naturalistic investigators begin to pay attention to classroom sub-settings.
Laughter was a low rate behavior relative to smiling. Laughter did not occur with sufficient frequency to differentiate individual subjects and there was no correlation of laughter to social interactions. The low frequency of laughter in this study suggests alternative settings for future investigations of laughter.
Results were discussed in relationship to mastery and attachment theories of smiling. Smiling was conceptualized as a potentially teachable social skill. The findings of the present study suggested the usefulness of a multiple-determinant model of smiling. Alternative research questions and strategies were proposed.
Thesis77b.D664.pdf
2.99 MB
Adobe PDF
f0b7403d26eb00a01aa3d4d759f4f6df