An examination of changes in the utility of interim financial information
General concern for interim financial reporting was manifested in the promulgation of Accounting Principles Board (APB) Opinion No. 28. The Opinion became effective for interim reports relating to fiscal years beginning in 1974. Prior to its release, there were no official pronouncements of objectives or appropriate accounting standards regarding interim financial statements. In absence of guidelines, two prominent interim reporting approaches emerged: the dependent period and the independent period approaches. Evidence indicated that the independent period approach was most frequently used in years prior to the Opinion.
Consistent with views of accounting theorists, the APB implicitly endorsed the dependent period approach. This approach regards each interim period as an integral part of the annual period. The APB encouraged firms to prepare interim data which better related to annual results. Because of the financial community's increasing interest in interim reporting and the recommendations in Opinion No. 28, the purpose of this study was to examine changes in the utility of interim financial information for the years 1972-1975.
A four-phased methodology was implemented. First, a questionnaire was developed and sent to financial executives of 200 companies. The survey was to determine whether the independent or dependent period approach was most frequently used and to identify firms which changed approaches in each year of the study period. Second, changes in the predictive ability of quarterly Net Sales, Income Before Extraordinary Items and Discontinued Operations, and Earnings Per Share--Before Extraordinary Items and Discontinued Operations were tested. Three naive forecast models were utilized to predict annual amounts for each variable from first, second, and third quarter data for the years 1972-1975. Third, the Capital Asset Pricing Model was adopted to assess changes in stock market reaction to first, second, and third quarter and annual earnings reports for the test period. Fourth, chi-square tests examined the association between measures of quarterly predictive ability and market reaction.
It was concluded for the four-year period that: (1) the independent period concept was slightly more frequently used and few firms changed reporting approaches, (2) generally, there were no significant changes in the predictive ability of tested quarterly variables, (3) investors reacted strongly to quarterly and annual earnings announcements but there was no evidence of a basic change in response magnitude within each report category, and (4) there was no consistent association between firm-specific changes of predictive ability and market reaction.
Thesis77b.D472.pdf
11.57 MB
Adobe PDF
c669e7ad036726b76b8fa6cd662fb066