The testing of a home economics energy conservation curriculum guide
This research study provided for the testing of a high school home economics curriculum guide for energy conservation, Energy Conservation in the Home. The evaluation of the guide included both internal evaluation by the development team and field-testing.
The field test was conducted with the cooperation of the Tennessee State Board of Education in high school home economics programs with 129 teachers and their intact groups of students participating. The Solomon Four-Group Design was employed as a research model for testing the effects of utilizing the curriculum guide on student opinion and knowledge. The independent t-test, correlated t-test, analysis of covariance, and two-way ANOVA comprised the statistical analysis. Group mean scores for knowledge and opinion of 2411 students comprising 107 groups were used as data for the statistical analyses.
Two treatments designated A and B were administered. Treatment A consisted of two levels: the utilization of the guide to teach energy conservation in secondary home economics, and the lack of the use of the guide. The presence of pre- and posttesting, and the presence of posttesting only, constituted Treatment B levels. The treatments were randomly assigned.
The four experimental groups consisted of (1) subject groups who had use of the guide and were posttested only; (2) subject groups who had use of the guide and were pre- and posttested; (3) subject groups who had no use of the guide and were posttested only; and (4) subject groups who had no use of the guide and were pre- and posttested. Immediately preceding the field test, the pretested groups were administered Opinion and Knowledge Evaluations developed by the researcher. All the groups were posttested with the Opinion and Knowledge Evaluations.
Eight sections of the guide (3, House: The Shell; 4, Environmental Control; 5, Housing Selection; 6, Food; 7, Clothing; 8, Personal Care; 9, Entertainment; and 10, Improving Energy Conservation in the Home) were tested independently. Teachers were given their choice of sections for field-testing.
The statistical analysis indicated that Section 6, Food, had a significant effect at the .05 level on both knowledge and opinion; Section 7, Clothing, on opinion; and Section 8, Personal Care, on knowledge. However, the remaining sections of the guide tested afforded no significant effects on either knowledge or opinion. The effects of pretesting were significant at the .05 level only for Section 6, Food, on knowledge.
In addition, participating teachers who were given the guide were asked to complete a Guide Evaluation Form. The results of the Guide Evaluation Forms indicated that the majority of teachers participating in the study rated the guide above average in terms of usefulness and effectiveness.
The guide was refined in response to the evaluation prior to final printing. The revised guide was then distributed nationally for replication and dissemination.
Thesis77b.C623.pdf
8.4 MB
Adobe PDF
e013d5e4371a5ea4111b9d6372e50d8b