Perceived parent-child relationships of obese and non-obese female college students
In an attempt to explore a potential emotional motivation for overeating and consequent obesity, a comparison was made between obese and nonobese female college students on their perception of maternal and paternal behavior. It was proposed that daughters who perceived a poor relationship with their parents might deal with the conflict by overeating. The Family Relations Inventory and the Parent-Child Relations Questionnaire II were used to probe for potential differences between the two groups. Weight was the independent variable. The subscales of these two instruments functioned as dependent variables. Thus, accepting, concentrating, avoiding, loving, demanding, attending, rejecting, and casual parental behaviors were the dependent variables.
A purposive (judgmental) sample of 26 obese and 26 nonobese female students were selected from two undergraduate college campuses. Obesity was defined as 30% or more above ideal weight for age, height, and body frame, whereas normal weight was defined as within 10% of ideal weight for age, height, and body frame. Ideal weight was determined by the Metropolitan Life Desirable Weight Chart for women. All subjects were middle-class, age 22 or under, Caucasian, and from intact families.
The researcher worked in cooperation with college administrators and head residents of women's dormitories to generate lists of students who appeared to be obese and lists of students who appeared to be of normal weight on each campus. Potential subjects were mailed letters describing the project and mentioning the name of the cooperating college
administrator and/or head resident who had suggested their name as a student who might be willing to participate in the research project. Appointments were arranged with those students who agreed to participate in the study. At the meeting, volunteers were requested to complete a brief background questionnaire and to respond to the two research instruments. Participants were asked to indicate their height, weight, and body frame as part of the background information. The researcher met with each participant individually; therefore, she was able to observe apparent discrepancies in reported height, weight, and body frame.
Multivariate and univariate analyses of variance were used to analyze the data. A general comparison between the two groups indicated a difference between the obese and nonobese womens' perception of parental behavior. The major difference between the two groups was the perception of paternal behavior. The differences appeared to focus around five of the dependent variables: acceptance, love, attention, rejection, and casualness. Generally, the obese women as compared to the nonobese women were characterized by their perception of lower paternal acceptance, lower paternal love, lower paternal attention, greater paternal rejection, and lower paternal casualness. Future research should focus on determining the temporal order of perceived parental rejection and the onset of obesity.
Thesis77b.C389.pdf
5.11 MB
Adobe PDF
5cd285e006042e19f9da070777c40d24