Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Doctoral Dissertations
  5. The effects of a motivational treatment course on the self-concept and work value structures of trustee inmates of a maximum security prison
Details

The effects of a motivational treatment course on the self-concept and work value structures of trustee inmates of a maximum security prison

Date Issued
December 1977
Author(s)
Bechtel, Thomas Bowman, 1940-
Advisor(s)
Donald V. Brown
Additional Advisor(s)
Charles Achilles
Gerald Cheek
Ken Owen McCullough
Donald V. Brown
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/60118
Abstract

Poor self concept is a major problem among incarcerated adult inmates in the establishment of correctional programs. Little is known about the effects of motivational treatment programs upon the self concepts and work value structures of adult incarcerates. This information would be most helpful in the prediction of postrelease employment success and the subsequent reduction of recidivism.

The major purpose of the study was to investigate the effects of the Guides for Better Living (GFBL) course on the self concepts and work values of maximum security trustee inmates. An additional purpose was to examine the relationship between self concept and work values to determine if a change in the former would be associated with a change in the latter. A third purpose was to measure the effect on mean subscale results when the scores from a nonrandomized group of coinstructors were pooled with the experimental group scores.

The Posttest-Only Control Group Design was used in this study. This design was used with a treatment and control group to assess significant differences after the treatment group had experienced 12 class sessions of Guides for Better Living course training over a 6-week treatment period.

A subject population consisting of 24 adult male resident volunteers from the trustee population at Brushy Mountain Penitentiary, Petros, Tennessee, were utilized in this study. Ten subjects were randomly assigned to each of the experimental and control groups. The remaining group consisted of 4 inmate constructors who were not randomly assigned and who had participated in a week-long training seminar conducted 2 weeks prior to the treatment program.

All subjects were informed, as required by law, that they were participating in a research project which would evaluate their self concepts and work value orientations. No incentives were offered. The only qualifying criterion was that the inmate be incarcerated long enough to complete the treatment course.

The treatment and coinstructor groups attended 12 two-hour class sessions which were based upon the principles of the Guides for Better Living course developed by Henry Aldefer, Napolean Hill, and Clement Stone. Twenty-four hours of instruction were offered. Classes were conducted each Monday and Friday evening beginning June 20, 1977, and extending through July 29, 1977. The classes were conducted in the visitor's gallery at Brushy Mountain Penitentiary, Petros, Tennessee.

At the conclusion of the course, the Work Values Inventory (WVI) developed by Donald Super and the Tennessee Self Concept Scale (TSCS) developed by William Fitts were administered orally to all participants. Data were collected on all subjects and analyzed with the aid of a 360/65 computer, the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, and the Statistical Analysis System "76." Both groups were compared using the t-test, Pearson's Product-Moment Correlation Coefficient, and ranks.

The following conclusions were gleaned from this study:

1. It was concluded that the GFBL course was effective in modifying the self concepts of the sample used in this study. Seven of the 12 subscales were reported as statistically significant.

2. The course time of 6 weeks was considered sufficient to produce some self concept change.

3. The experimental group, after completing the GFBL course, reported normal self concept scores on 9 of the 12 TSCS subscales, while two normal scores were reported for the control group. It was concluded from this finding that difference in the group profiles was attributed to the treatment course.

4. The experimental group was more sensitive to self criticism than was the control group. Control group response on this subscale was also more homogeneous.

5. Variability mean score for the experimental group was higher than that of the control group. It was concluded that the experimental group showed less unity between self concept measures than did the control group.

6. The self concept profiles of the control group tended to conform to the norms of subnormal populations, while the experimental group profiles were not. It was concluded from this finding that the self concepts of the experimental group more closely approximated the profiles of the average citizen.

7. Both the experimental and control groups indicated a high mean work value profile. It was concluded that there is among both groups a willingness to work or be engaged in work-related activities.

8. A high work value cluster of Security, Economic Returns, and Way of Life was reported by both the experimental and control groups. The conclusion from this finding was that both groups rated monetary rewards and those values associated with remuneration as most important.

9. The low work value cluster of the experimental group included the values of Variety, Management, and Surroundings, while Variety, Management, and Prestige were recorded by the control group. It was concluded from these data that both groups preferred an established work routine that was task oriented.

10. It was concluded from the pooled data analysis that there was a definite and positive trend in the subscale scores of the experimental group as contrasted with the control group. It was further concluded that the GFBL was having a positive effect upon the work values of those inmates who participated in the course.

11. It was concluded that in adult male incarcerates, self concept was not valid as a predictor of positive work value orientation.

The Guides for Better Living course, as taught at Brushy Mountain Prison, was considered to be effective in improving the work values and self concepts of the treatment participants. There was additional evidence that had the program continued, additional levels of significance would have been reached by the treatment subjects.

 
Degree
Doctor of Education
Major
Vocational - Technical Education
File(s)
Thumbnail Image
Name

Thesis77b.B4294.pdf

Size

7.03 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

907b87685b185302a4aed3c0117e6861


University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science