A review of reading comprehension research reported in journals from 1900 through 1975
Little is known about the area of reading comprehension. Experts in the field of reading have not provided us with an adequate definition of the term. The problem of defining reading comprehension is further compounded by the lack of any one source which identifies and reviews the major experimental studies that have attempted to deal with the topic. Since the ultimate goal of any research endeavor is to provide information to those individuals who can best initiate change or utilize that information most efficiently, this study was designed to meet the need for a basic evaluative source of information about the research in reading comprehension.
Specifically the study answered the following questions:
1. What research articles have been published in the United States pertaining to reading comprehension from 1900 through 1975 and are stored in the ERIC/CRIER Clearinghouse on Reading?
2. What specific areas of reading comprehension have been investigated by the researchers?
3. What is the relative merit of each of these experimental studies?
4. What types of research other than experimental have been conducted in the area of reading comprehension?
5. What conclusions can be drawn from the best of these experimental studies that will contribute to defining reading comprehension and formulating teaching strategies to develop this skill?
Although 549 articles were identified as reading comprehension research by the ERIC system, 364 of these were found to be "armchair" analyses. A total of 185 studies were reviewed. Each study was described in terms of topic, research question, major conclusions and relative merit. The relative merit of a study was determined by evaluating the research according to the Suydam Scale for Evaluating Experimental Research. This rating scale asked nine questions which deal with the research question, research design, sampling procedures, statistics used, and reporting procedures for the study. A five point scale is used for ranking each question so that an excellent report would score 9 points and a very poor report would receive 45 points.
An analysis of the data obtained from the 185 research reports led to the following conclusions:
1. Much of the research in reading comprehension is inadequate because of basic design flaws.
2. There is no experimental base which supports any of the more prevalent definitions of reading comprehension.
3. There is no research evidence which supports the teaching of specific skills in reading comprehension such as finding the main idea or detecting the sequence. The two dominant factors that appear to influence reading comprehension are one's word knowledge and reasoning ability.
4. Research in reading comprehension is fragmented. This study identified 21 different topic areas related to reading comprehension which had been investigated by the researchers. The easiest topic to identify and investigate appears to be reading rate. Several studies dealt with increasing rate to improve reading comprehension. No clear cut definition of reading comprehension could be formulated. No direct method for teaching or improving reading comprehension could be developed.
5. A majority of the studies identified were not experimental research but were correlational studies. These studies were examined but not evaluated. Their findings tend to support the data from the experimental studies which hypothesize that the major components of reading comprehension are vocabulary power and thinking ability.
As a result of this study researchers in the field of reading now have a tool which identifies and evaluates all the experimental research in the area of reading comprehension which is stored in the ERIC system. :
Thesis77b.B788.pdf
15.39 MB
Adobe PDF
82524880b118682cf4a8d267c4dc1ab1