Liberal elements in the political thought of Jonathan Boucher
Jonathan Boucher was a Loyalist political philosopher at the time of the American Revolution. He has been termed an ultra-conservative by most scholars of American political thought. It was my purpose in this thesis to show that this is a highly inaccurate characterization of Boucher and does not take into account certain segments of his thought that by most definitions would be termed liberal. These segments were Boucher's ideas on slavery, Indian policy, and religious toleration of Catholics. I hoped to show that in much of his thought Boucher was not very different from the revolutionaries and, indeed, in some aspects he was more liberal.
In order to do this, I searched the writings of Boucher, of other Loyalists, and of the American revolutionaries in order to compare their ideas. I also made extensive use of secondary materials on this era.
I found that in much of his political thought Boucher was very close to the founders of America. In his ideas on slavery, Indian policy, and toleration of Catholics, he held ideas that were much ahead of his time. He did not fit neatly into the ultra-conservative mold. I also found that colonial and early American society was not as liberal and democratic as we are sometimes led to believe by scholars. This myth of early American democracy is in part the reason that Boucher has been saddled with classification as a reactionary. Studying Boucher's thought has also cast further doubt on the terms "liberal" and "conservative" as adequate descriptions of political beliefs and behavior.
I concluded that the characterization of Boucher as an ultra-conservative was an erroneous one. It was a characterization that ignored certain aspects of Boucher's thought as well as the realities of early American political philosophy.
Thesis77.S464.pdf
6.28 MB
Adobe PDF
3a01d3950fd72dca04781d7af4528089