Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Doctoral Dissertations
  5. The deradicalization of the Japanese left?
Details

The deradicalization of the Japanese left?

Date Issued
August 1977
Author(s)
Fukai, Shigeko Nimiya
Advisor(s)
Joseph W. Dodd
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/60059
Abstract

The purpose of this study is to examine the extent to which the two Marxist parties of Japan-the Japan Communist Party (JCP) and the Japan Socialist Party (JSP) - have deradicalized their doctrines and practices following the trend in the industrialized West that has led to the formulation of a series of "decline of ideology" hypotheses. Compared with the abundance of studies that examine the validity of the hypotheses in the Western European context, no systematic study focusing on both the JCP and the JSP has been made in order to examine the applicability of the decline theme to Japan-an industrialized but non-Western country. This study attempts to to fill this void.

While the "decline of ideology" hypotheses concern changes in (1) the Party doctrines and practices, (2) the Party leaders' beliefs and attitudes, and (3) the Party's social base, this study focuses on the first and second categories of change. Using a two-dimensional analytical scheme that classifies four types of radicalism or deradicalization, namely, (1) genuine, explicit radicalism, (2) concealed radicalism (or spurious deradicalization), (3) concealed deradicalization (or spurious radicalism), and (4) genuine, explicit deradicalization, the major Party documents, Party leaders' writings, scholarly works, and newspaper reports are examined in order to identify and describe changes in the doctrines and practices of the JCP and the JSP during the period 1945-1975. In addition, the interview and questionnaire data are analyzed in order to ascertain the strength of the Party leaders' totalitarian and authoritarian tendencies, two major attitudinal elements of revolutionary Marxism. The interview-questionnaire data are analyzed also to ascertain (1) the leaders' attitude toward "traditional" Japanese values and attitudes in order to clarify the nature of their "antisystem" orientation, and (2) their perception of those environmental and organizational changes presumably causing the deradicalization of Western European Marxist parties, in order to ascertain the "subjective" source of radicalisms of the Japanese Left.

It is found that, through their postwar existence, a high level of doctrine-practice congruence-a hallmark of radicalism-has characterized the JCP and the Shakaishugi Kyokai (Socialism Society), the JSP's leftmost intraparty group, whereas a widening discrepancy between revolutionism in doctrine and rhetoric, on the one hand, and essentially within-system practices, on the other, has marked the parliamentary left-wing of the JSP. Thus, while the JSP parliamentary left wing exemplifies spurious radicalism, leftist radicalism seems to survive in the JCP and the Kyokai, although with significant differences in its nature.

Despite "liberal-democratization" in its conspicuous aspects of doctrine (such as rejection of the dictatorship of the proletariat) and system practices (such as emphasis on electoral and parliamentary activities), the JCP still retains fundamentally anti-liberal democratic goal orientation. The Party also manifests the Stalinist heritage in its organizational doctrine and intraparty practices and in its insistence on the "vanguard" role in relations with other parties,

"New Left" groups, and mass movements. In contrast, Kyokai radicalism has been conspicuous in its open advocacy of the working class dictatorship and in its frequent resort to militant direct action tactics against the government and management, although its organizational doctrine and practices seem to reveal its leaders' "genuine predilection for democratic processes."* Thus, the JCP may be placed in the category of concealed radicalism, whereas the Kyokai may be described as an example of genuine, explicit radicalism.

The interview-questionnaire data have confirmed this conclusion by suggesting the prevalence of totalitarian beliefs and authoritarian attitudes among the JCP leaders in contrast to strongly egalitarian (and hence anticapitalist) but essentially individualistic and liberal attitudes of the Kyokai leaders. It is also shown that the JCP leaders tended to show less concern with the presumably 'premodern' anti-individualism and related "nonrational" voting behavior prevailing among the Japanese masses than the Kyokai leaders who were particularly sensitive to the workers' "feudalistic" authoritarianism which they saw as blocking the normal development of class consciousness. The data also have revealed that the leaders' perception faithfully reflect the doctrinal viewpoints. The JCP leaders' radicalism seemed to be inspired mainly by the strong sense of crisis they felt against the "two enemies," Japanese monopoly capitalism and "American imperialism." In contrast,

The phrase is from Alfred Meyer's description of Marx and Engels: "Their own hard-headedness was often in conflict with their refined taste or their genuine predilection for democratic processes." Marxism, p. 117.

the major perceptual factor sustaining the Kyokai radicalism seemed to be the massive injustices they find in serious material and psychological problems faced by the industrial workers under rapid "capitalistic rationalization" enforced by the government and management and in the "revisionist" trends growing within the JSP and the labor movement. This unity of doctrine and perception indicates that the sloganization of doctrine introduced initially for mass mobilization purpose has come seriously to distort the perception of those Party leaders who were supposed to control the selection of slogans depending on changes in the mass moods and the objective conditions in general. Thus, one major obstacle for deradicalization of both the JCP and the Kyokai seems to be the leaders' failure constantly to distinguish two functions of doctrine-one as an ideological tool (for symbolic purposes) and the other as an analytical tool (for policy-guiding purposes).

The interview data, however, revealed some significant signs for change. While essentially antitotalitarian and antiauthoritarian attitudes seem to be emerging among a minority of the JCP leaders, the Kyokai leaders' deep-seated liberal individualistic disposition might gradually come to the surface as the Kyokai increases Diet seats in the future. Thus, it seems possible that, if they are allowed continuously to participate in the existing parliamentary processes as a significant political force, changes toward genuine deradicalization would take place within the JCP and the Kyokai.

 
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Political Science
File(s)
Thumbnail Image
Name

Thesis77b.F752.pdf

Size

28.37 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

02f2e614b50db32e28fa4eb916d4c5bb


University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science