An empirical analysis of the impact of selected audit opinion qualifications on the market risk components
Attestation regarding the degree to which a firm's financial statements are fairly presented is among the most basic services provided by the public accounting profession. The profession recognizes that a significant aspect of the attest function is its contribution to the communicative effectiveness of financial reporting.
Financial literature widely recognizes that the valuation of any asset is determined by its risk and return characteristics. The Financial Accounting Standards Board formally recognizes that only those disclosures apprising investors about risk and return constitute relevant information. Thus, attestation, as an independent assessment of the quality of financial information, can be viewed as conveying information regarding relative risk and returns.
The objective of this study is to determine the apparent informational impact of audit opinions containing either consistency or uncertainty qualifications. Their impact is measured by their apparent effect on the capital market risk components, elements of the widely recognized financial market model.
Based on certain general and opinion pattern criteria, samples of firms receiving qualified opinions and related control samples of firms receiving only unqualified opinions were selected from Accounting Trends and Techniques. Changes in risk components were measured for each sample company for two 36-month time spans prior and subsequent to each tested audit report. Chi-square tests were applied to the data measuring the time-series changes in systematic and unsystematic risk. Analyses supported the expectation that no significant differences in changes of the risk components existed between the samples.
This study indicates that audit opinions containing either consistency or uncertainty qualifications apparently have little impact on the risk components and thus, are only of marginal informational value to aggregate investor groups. Also, results of this study analyzing risk measures support conclusions of market efficiency found in earlier studies analyzing security returns.
An ancillary phase of this study involved cross-sectional analyses of comparative risk levels between control and experimental samples. No significant differences in risk levels were noted between the sample of firms receiving consistency qualifications and the related control sample. However, firms receiving uncertainty qualifications consistently exhibited significantly greater levels of unsystematic risk than those firms that received only unqualified opinions. This behavior may logically result from relatively large adjustments of the security's price by the market as a result of changes in perceptions regarding future security returns.
Findings of this study, to the effect that audit opinions qualified for consistency or uncertainty have little informational impact, raise important questions regarding the function of these qualified opinions and serve as a basis for the identification of several related areas of important research.
Thesis77b.A560.pdf
7.11 MB
Adobe PDF
21dcc1db2cea02063d668fe5e7aa7f15