A quasi-experimental study of reading achievement and reading attitudes in multiage and traditional student groupings
Historically, parents and educators have emphasized the need for learning to read as having priority over any other skill acquisition during the primary grades. Young students spend a large portion of their day participating in a variety of activities designed to enhance reading performance. Educators realize the impact of a variety of factors which may complicate or strengthen reading achievement. Attitude toward reading has emerged as one of those factors. The complexity of the relationship between attitude and the reading process may be compounded when other correlates are considered. The question raised in this study concentrated on the influence of student grouping strategies on the development of reading achievement and attitudes toward reading.
This study focused specifically on the traditional chronological student grouping strategy and the multiage student grouping strategy to examine whether or not differences and/or relationships existed between reading achievement and reading attitudes of students which have participated in each of these grouping strategies for no less than a consecutive three year period. First grade and third grade total reading achievement test scores served as pre- and posttest measures on each student. The Heathington Primary Reading Attitude Scale was used to measure reading attitudes for each student.
Data were collected from a total of 46 students in a Tennessee elementary school which offers a choice for parents of either student grouping strategy. Analysis of the data using a one way analysis of variance, an analysis of covariance and the Pearson r rendered the following: 1) There was no significant difference between the total reading achievement test scores of students participating in either a traditional or multiage setting, 2) There was no significant difference between the attitudes toward reading of students participating in either a traditional or multiage setting, 3) There was no significant relationship between the total reading achievement score and the reading attitude score of students participating in a traditional setting and 4) There was a modest positive relationship between the total reading achievement and the reading attitude score of students participating in a multiage setting.
It was concluded that, for this particular sample, there are no significant differences in reading achievement and reading attitude of students that have participated in a multiage setting with students that have participated in a traditional setting for a three year period. A discussion of the conclusions, study limitations, and implications for teachers as well as future research were discussed.
Thesis94b.B495.pdf
3.95 MB
Adobe PDF
11585ece5dac70bfd25b636c3bd15752