The identification of potential leadership skills common to and developed through vocational student organizations
The study was designed to answer four research questions, the major one being to identify potential leadership skills of vocational student organizations. Other questions were designed to: (1) determine which of the potential leadership skills were common to all vocational student organizations, (2) determine if significant differences existed in perceptions of state advisers and state presidents regarding the opportunities to develop leadership skills, and (3) determine if significant differences existed in the opportunity to develop common potential leadership skills among respondent groups as categorized by VICA, DECA, FBLA, OEA, FHA, and FFA.
A complete census of state advisers and state presidents to vocational student organizations was attempted. A total of 459 state advisers and state presidents from the 48 contiguous states, Alaska, Hawaii, and Washington, D.C. were contacted to participate in the study. The data from 342 usable questionnaires were subjected to various statistical treatments.
The following findings were a result of the analysis and interpretations of the data:
1. The national executive directors of vocational student organizations validated 98 potential leadership skills for vocational student organizations. The survey instrument was composed of those 98 potential leadership skills. The Cronbach Alpha procedure established the reliability of the instrument to be .973.
2. State advisers and state presidents determined that 85 leadership skills were common to the six vocational student organizations based on mean ratings of four or higher on a Likert-type scale which ranged from a low of 1.0 to a high of 6.0.
3. There were 75 significant differences at the .05 level as a result of t test comparisons of the 600 mean scores of state advisers and state presidents in rating the potential leadership skills. Sixty-eight of those differences were rated significantly higher by state presidents in the degree of opportunity to develop those leadership skills. State presidents for FHA and FFA reported 52 of the significantly higher means.
4. Cochran's C test indicated that 53 of the 85 common leadership skills supported the assumption of equal variances significant at the .05 level.
5. The one-way analysis of variance was used to compare the six groups (VICA, DECA, FBLA, OEA, FFA, and FHA) in terms of mean scores on the 53 items which supported the assumption of equal variances. The analysis of variance indicated a significant F ratio at the .05 level for 36 of the items. Scheffé's multiple comparison test was used as follow-up analysis of the data. Respondents for FHA and FFA gave significantly higher mean scores for 21 of the 22 items which indicated significant differences by Scheffé's multiple comparison.
6. The Kruskal-Wallis ANOVA determined significant differences for those 32 items which were lacking in homogeneity of variances. This procedure indicated significant chi-square values for 25 items. The 25 mean ranks with significant differences based on the Kruskal-Wallis test were further analyzed by the Gibbons' multiple comparison procedure. The Gibbons' multiple comparison procedure indicated 91 significant differences for the 375 comparisons. Sixty-two of the significantly higher values were reported by FHA and FFA respondents.
Five conclusions were presented based on the review of literature, the questionnaire, and the results of statistical analysis. Seven recommendations were offered in view of the findings and conclusions derived from the study. Two selected recommendations are:
1. The leadership skills having a mean score of 5 and above should provide direction for structuring activities within vocational student organizations.
2. Persons responsible for teacher education programs should give consideration to the development of competencies needed by advisers to vocational student organizations.
The discussion of the results of the study provides suggestions regarding possible applications of the study.
Thesis79b.B32.pdf
8.33 MB
Adobe PDF
8475114cac11ca38825c791fcf1ac846