Lay perceptions of the thirteenth and fourteenth century English parish clergy as reflected in contemporary literature
The purpose of this study was to discover common perceptions of the English parish clergy held by men and women of the thirteenth and fourteenth century, and to detect any significant changes in attitude over the course of the two centuries. After these perceptions were determined, an attempt was made to explain these attitudes in light of the contemporary social situation and the conditions of parish life in late medieval England. The thirteenth and fourteenth centuries were chosen as the time period because of several important developments and events which occurred during this period. The thirteenth century witnessed the emergence of a popular religious movement, espoused by the Franciscans and Dominicans, which expressed a dissatisfcation with the state of the organized Church and a desire to return to a purer practice of Christianity. Also, in the first half of the fourteenth century, the Plague broke out in England, greatly affecting many aspects of English life. In the late medieval period, the parish priest was an important part of the everyday lives of most men and women; it was hoped that such a traumatic era would produce literature in which the parish priest and his role would be a topic of popular concern.
The sources for this study consisted mainly of primary literary works such as chronicles, poems, songs, and narratives. An examination of the ideas contained in these works constituted the major portion of the study. Secondary works concerned with the medieval English parish, religious history, and general histories of the period were employed to determine the social setting in which men and women of the late medieval period lived.
A close examination of the literary works of this period revealed several definite attitudes toward the parish clergy; however, there were three topics that appeared to be of primary interest to medieval writers. These were clerical celibacy, clerical illiteracy, and clerical greed; of these three, clerical greed was the topic which was of the most concern. The medieval parishioner preferred that the parish priest was at least fairly literate and that he abide by his vow of celibacy; the only instances of vehement criticism of illiteracy or incontinency were in conjunction with criticism that the priest was neglecting his responsibilities as the spiritual leader of the parish. Greed, on the other hand, was the most detested of vices in a priest and one which. received the most vituperative attacks. The reason for this, it would seem, was that of the three vices, greed had the most negative impact upon the life of the average parishioner, for the parish priest held the threat of excommunication if a parishioner did not meet his financial obligations to the Church.
While illiteracy, incontinency, and greed were themes in the literature of both the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, a comparison of the literature of both periods revealed that literature of the later period contained more numerous and bitter criticisms of the parish clergy as a whole. Condemnation was directed toward the priesthood as a class, not merely individual erring priests, as was characteristic of thirteenth century literature. This shift in attitude seems to be related to two very important phenomena of the fourteenth century-the Black Death and the Avignon Papacy.
Thesis80.M6584.pdf
3.01 MB
Adobe PDF
7e853d3040bd36af721459b0a41f69b9