The effectiveness of hydroxyethyl cellulose as a partial replacement for phosphate in detergent systems
The main objective of this research was to determine the most effective combination of hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC) and sodium tripolyphosphate (STPP) of those studied in a detergent formulated with 16% sodium p-tridecylbenzenesulfonate (anionic surfactant) and 8% ethoxylated linear fatty alcohol (nonionic surfactant). Also, it was the intention of this research to investigate the effect of two water hardness levels, 100 and 200 parts per million (ppm) on the soil removal ability of the formulated detergents.
Sixteen detergents were formulated for the study with the levels of hydroxyethyl cellulose as 0, 2.5, 5.0 and 7.5% and those of sodium tripolyphosphate as 12, 16, 20 and 24%. The mixed surfactant system was the same for all detergents.
The detergents were tested under both levels of water hardness upon a partially presoiled 65/35 polyester cotton fabric with a durable press finish. Total light reflectance readings were made of the soiled and the unsoiled portions of each fabric initially and after one laundering. These readings were used to calculate percent soil removal and percent soil redeposition for each experimental condition.
With the data calculated from reflectance readings, a Three-Way Analysis of Variance was done with the independent variables being HEC, STPP and water hardness. Separate analyses were run for the two dependent variables, percent soil removal and percent soil redeposition.
Results of the statistical analysis for percent soil redeposition show that each detergent formulation was able to prevent soil redeposition from occurring under either level of water hardness. This was reflected in a negative mean percent soil redeposition value for each detergent.
For percent soil removal, the most effective detergent formulation with 100 ppm water hardness was found to be 5.0% HEC and 16.0% STPP. Under the same water hardness level, 24% STPP (at all levels of HEC) exhibited much lower soil removal values than the other experimental conditions. Excluding the anomalous behavior of 24% STPP at 100 ppm, the overall mean percent soil removal tended to be higher at 100 ppm than at 200 ppm. All combinations of HEC and STPP worked effectively at 200 ppm water hardness with 7.5% HEC and 20% STPP as a slightly more effective combination.
Thesis77.J658.pdf
2.31 MB
Adobe PDF
cc2b3d1206c74ff90517df356fd1fdfb