Gender roles and patterns of delinquency
Most writers explain the sex differential in delinquency by tracing a linkage from sex to delinquency through gender identification. Boys are presumed to be more delinquent than girls because they are more masculine. Girls are thought to evidence low involvement in rule-breaking behaviors because they are feminine in gender orientation. This study investigated the widespread assumptions in the criminological literature that there is a natural or obvious connection between gender identification as masculine or feminine and patterns of delinquency involvement. Masculine persons may also be more delinquent than feminine persons because individuals with masculine orientation are less attached to conventional others, less committed to and involved in conventional action, less believing that societal rules should be obeyed and more likely to encounter social support for delinquent activities than are feminine persons.
To operationalize the concepts of masculine and feminine gender identification, two instruments were developed. These instruments were found to be both valid and reliable in measuring the independent variables of masculine and feminine gender identification. A self-report scale was used to measure the dependent variable of the frequency of delinquency. Indices were constructed to assess variations in attachment, commitment, involvement, belief, and social support. The data concerning the associations of these variables included crosstabulations and gammas for the relationship of masculinity and femininity to delinquency and for these bivariate associations when the social control and support variables and sex were held constant.
Contrary to the assumptions in the literature, the responses of this sample of adolescents do not confirm the existence of linkages from sex to delinquency through masculine or feminine self-expectations. Sex is related to delinquency regardless of gender identification. The association of masculinity to delinquency disappears when sex is held constant. No relationship at all exists between femininity and delinquency for members of either sex.
Most of the variables of social control and support do not relate to masculinity or feminity but associate moderately to strongly with delinquency. Support is found for the contentions that the elements of social control constrain involvement in delinquency and that the opportunity for delinquency in the form of social support provides resources facilitating delinquency. The social control factors do not, however, link gender to delinquency. Only the social support for delinquency alters the relationship between gender identification and rule-breaking behaviors, but this effect must be treated with caution since there are methodological difficulties with the small cell frequencies and sample size.
Thesis77.J338.pdf
4 MB
Adobe PDF
ae8b58f56048e81e399582c2020ae658