Effects of individual and group incentives on individual performance
There has been little research on the use of money as a motivational tool. Neither the proponents nor the opponents of the use of monetary rewards provide empirical evidence for their points of view. Some authors contend the use of payment by results has been justifiably declining in recent years, while others insist that this impression is not borne out by available data. This study tested the relative efficacy of individual versus group incentives under controlled laboratory conditions. It was hypothesized that individual incentives stimulate greater quantity of individual output, particularly with independent tasks; group incentives stimulate higher quality of individual output, particularly with interdependent tasks. Quantity and quality were hypothesized to be inversely related.
The independent variables were task and bonus. The dependent variables were quantity and quality of output. Three levels of bonus (no bonus, individual bonus, and group bonus) were awarded to participants (n=108) contingent on performance in either an independent task situation, in which subjects solved multiplication problems in isolation, or an interdependent task situation, in which the problems were solved on a group basis.
Results showed that quantity of output was higher in independent task conditions with individual bonuses, as predicted, but not in interdependent task conditions with individual bonuses, which was not anticipated. Quantity of output in interdependent tasks was higher with group bonuses. Quality of output was less predictable, but results suggested that quality was higher with group bonuses regardless of the task. No relationship between quantity and quality of production was observed.
Thesis82.C423.pdf
1.77 MB
Adobe PDF
762fa18e5604f6a89391cb19019ec0da