A comparison of organizational climate responses using formal and functional grouping techniques
In this study an attempt was made to compare the effect of formal and functional grouping techniques on organizational climate response data. It was hypothesized that climate responses grouped by functional (e.g. psychological) instead of formal (e.g. organizational chart) techniques would result in smaller within group and greater between group response variances. Formal groups were determined using the organizational chart and supervisory work groups, while functional groups were determined by NEGOPY, a communication network analysis. Organizational climate data were collected using a derivative of the Survey of Organizations questionnaire which measured five factors of organizational climate. Data were collected from two departments within a large, private manufacturing organization; one department was production orientated while the other was financial.
The results of the network analysis indicated that the overall formal group (the department) and the functional group for each department were identical. Due to these results the original hypothesis could neither be accepted nor rejected. An analysis of variance of climate factor responses produced results which offered support of the small variance within functional group assumption, since there were no significant differences between formal work group responses means within 9 of the 10 analyses. A test for homogeneity also indicated a substantial degree of homogeneity among work groups on most climate factor responses.
No firm conclusions or specific answers could be derived from the results concerning the utility of formal and functional grouping techniques of organizational climate responses. It appears that future research is needed in this area before solid conclusions may be made. This study and its results do provide the rationale and direction for the future research in the area of functional and formal grouping techniques of organizational climate and other psychological responses within organizations.
Thesis77.R455.pdf
2.93 MB
Adobe PDF
38b85d6373a66e74623fcd97a8c389b7