Children's understanding of television commercials : a cognitive development study
This thesis deals with a subject of growing concern: television advertising directed to children. The study is approached from a cognitive development vantage, a branch of developmental psychology.
The subject is one that has received significant attention only since the early 1970s when Action for Children's Television (ACT) was formed.
The purpose of the study was to determine the levels of cognitive development at which young children could evaluate the purpose of television commercials directed to them.
Cognitive development is broken down into three stages by its two leading figures--Jean Piaget and Jerome Bruner. The stages are broken down thusly: (1) Piaget's sensorimotor period or Bruner's enactive period; (2) Piaget's concrete operational period or Bruner's ikonic period; and, (3) Piaget's period of formal operations or Bruner's symbolic period. Piaget's second stage is broken down into two periods, the first of which he calls the pre-operational period. The second part of the second stage is referred to as the concrete period. This study deals with Piaget's pre-operational, concrete operational and formal operational periods.
Fifty-eight children from a grade school in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, were personally interviewed by the author. Grades 1, 3, and 6 were chosen on the assumption that these grades would correspond to the cognitive levels of pre-operational, concrete operational and formal operational, respectively. However, grade 3 split between the pre-operational and concrete operational stages. Therefore, a fourth grade sample was included to obtain the desired balance of the cognitive stages.
The children were given a Piagetian-based conservation-of-liquid task and a complex verbal task to determine their level of cognitive development. The questionnaire was then administered and the results were tabulated according to the individual child's level of cognitive development. The levels at which children's answers were categorized were based on Ward (1972).
The hypothesis of the study was that before reaching the stage of formal operations, children could not evaluate the purpose of television commercials directed to them.
From the findings obtained in the study it appears that the data support the hypothesis. Children in the pre-operational, and to a large extent the concrete operational, stages were naive in regard to the purpose of television advertising.
Thesis77.H547.pdf
2.09 MB
Adobe PDF
bd844913e56a351e66b5c97aae67cb05