A phenomenology of film signification
This study is an attempt to understand how we make sense out of films when we talk about them. A major purpose of the study is to explore a way of bridging the gap between film theory and film research, by applying the phenomenological method to the generation of film theory. The study is phenomenological in that it seeks to describe the film-viewing experiences of a group of people after having taken part in the experiences with them, instead of testing hypotheses or manipulating variables. This is a field study which uses participant observation as a research tool.
Chapter I offers a survey of three areas which are crucial to the orientation assumed by the present study: film research, contemporary rhetorical theory, and phenomenological theory. Chapter II clarifies the phenomenological method which is used in this study. Chapter III describes the research setting for this study: a film discussion group consisting of myself and seven members of a class which I was teaching on "Women and Film." Chapter IV is the analysis of the discussion transcripts and written material provided by the participants, and Chapter V discusses the problem of the intersubjective nature of film signification in relation to the analysis in Chapter IV.
Phenomenological analysis of the data resulted in a syntactic propositional model of the film signification process, a way of describing what we do when we make sense out of a film. Chapter IV provides 100 examples from the data in order to "teach" the reader this method of reflecting on the naive film-viewing experience. This study documents the process of change in people's film-viewing abilities in terms of the development of "propositional competency," or the punctuation of the perceptual flux into coherent units of meaning. Although the analysis resulted in a linguistic model of film signification, it does not directly support the notion that film can be regarded as a language; rather, these findings indicate that our experience of a film operates in linguistic manner. A significant conclusion of this study is that the phenomenological method can be useful in generating film theory, although it has only rarely been used in the past.
Thesis77.C769.pdf
9.32 MB
Adobe PDF
408e3ec144fae18a39b556bb224499fc