An analysis of the authority system of a public housing agency homemaker program for elderly and disabled residents
The purpose of this study was to analyze the authority system of a public housing agency homemaker program for elderly and disabled residents and to explore the impact of this system upon the program's service output. The Homemaker Program of the Metropolitan Development and Housing Agency (MDHA) in Nashville, Tennessee was selected for analysis on the basis of research previously conducted by this author which indicated inadequate service output during the period from January 1 to March 31, 1976. Service output was assessed in terms of service approved by the supervisor but not provided, services provided without prior approval, and degree of homemaker conformity to existing schedules. It was assumed that these characteristics of the service output were affected by the authority system in existence at that time.
The present study was based upon a review of theories and concepts in the area of authority and authority systems in formal organizations and an analysis of the service network of the MDHA Homemaker Program. The Homemaker Program authority system was assessed by utilizing authority system models and criteria for effectiveness derived from review of the literature.
It was determined that the MDHA Homemaker Program authority system incorporated aspects of several models rather than corresponding with a particular model. Major incongruities were found between the MDHA Homemaker Program and the criteria for an effective authority system. These included inadequate delegation of authority to positions of responsibility, lack of direct supervision, subjectivity of the evaluation process, and ambiguous procedures and communication processes.
It was concluded that the ineffective performance of the control function resulting from these structural deficiencies allowed homemakers inappropriate discretion and, thus, contributed to faulty judgements regarding service provision.
From the analysis of the MDHA Homemaker Program authority system, a number of propositions regarding authority in homemaker programs were generated. These were as follows:
1. The authority system of a homemaker program directly affects the service output of that program.
2. A relationship exists between the inadequate service output of a homemaker program and deficiencies in the structure and operation of its authority system.
3. The authority and responsibility for supervision and evaluation of homemakers should be vested in a position having direct contact with the homemaker at the point of service provision.
4. Authority and responsibility vested in a position must be equivalent to assure successful task accomplishment.
5. Specific goals, procedures, and regulations must be established and communicated for maximum staff performance.
6. The evaluation procedure must measure homemaker performance accurately and consistently and must directly influence the distribution of rewards and negative sanctions.
The propositions developed as a result of this study can be utilized as a basis for further research in the area of authority in formal organizations. Due to the impact of the authority system on organizational productivity, additional research is needed to determine cause/effect relationships between characteristics of authority systems and service output. This is particularly essential in homemaker programs operated by public housing agencies, since caseloads are large and staff and supportive resources are minimal.
Thesis77.C244.pdf
2.67 MB
Adobe PDF
6ae7fafd4cbebf1aceeaf55b47990ab3