The development of a procedure for the instructional cost analysis of physical education programs in higher education
The purpose of this study was to develop an instructional course cost analysis procedure that would allow physical education administrators to gain a new perspective on the costs of instructional programs. Since present cost analysis techniques are limited in their budgetary structures and procedures for analyzing costs, an analytical method that would structurally indicate more precisely salary and support costs for individual programs and courses is needed.
Following a comprehensive examination of institutional budget structures and costing methodology, an instructional cost analysis procedure was developed based on the Faculty Contact and Faculty Credit Hours for analyzing collegiate physical education programs.
Administrators of physical education programs at eight public four-year institutions in the State of Tennessee consented to supply financial data and information relating to their academic programs. Once the collection process was completed, instructional costs were computed and analyzed for individual courses and programs at each institution.
From the analyzed data and responses from the administrators to questions pertaining to the proposed Physical Education Course Cost Analysis (PECCA) procedure, two conclusions were drawn. First, the PECCA is a workable procedure for conducting an instructional cost analysis. This procedure appears especially suitable for costing different programs within the curriculum since data are analyzed in terms of Faculty Credit Hours (FCRH) and Faculty Contact Hours (FCOH). Secondly, this proposed procedure will provide a tool whereby an institution's administrator may determine how much it costs to operate and maintain specific academic programs within the curriculum and to plan program expansions more economically.
Based on information received during the personal interviews and the finalized cost analysis, several observations were also made:
1. Low instructional costs should not necessarily imply instructional efficiency. Factors such as rank of instructor, class enrollment, and number of sections offered greatly affect the costs of particular programs.
2. Generally speaking, service programs will cost less per student because of graduate teaching assistants and junior faculty assigned to activity courses.
3. The idea that instructional costs increase with higher level courses should be an accepted principle.
4. The awareness of resource utilization and its associated cost implications should be heightened through the use of the analyzation of program costs with this procedure. This developed costing methodology aids the administrator in realizing more precisely the allocation of support costs and how they affect overall instructional costs.
5. While the costs of instructional programs should not become the only basis for budgetary decision making, they should be given careful and proper consideration. The developed instructional cost analysis presents objective cost data but does not reflect the quality and effectiveness of instructional programs and individual courses.
6. During the decision making process relating to budget cuts of particular programs based on the analyzed data, several costs should be considered. By having more than one cost measure for instructional programs (Faculty Credit Hour, Faculty Contact Hour, Average Cost Per Class, Average Cost Per Student, Cost Per Student Credit Hour), several factors affecting program costs may be identified and evaluated.
7. Because of departmental differences, institutional comparison of cost data may be misleading. These differences included academic term, use of athletic staff for instructional purposes, staff rankings, and amount of support monies available.
8. In some instances course credit is given for varsity athletic practices. Being a part of the service program, these courses are allotted comparable hours for course credit as other activity courses. Because varsity practices total between 10-20 hours per week, the number of contact hours allocated to these service program courses may result in a misleading cost analysis if based on Faculty Contact Hours (FCOH).
9. While athletic staff salaries are supplemented on a 50 percent basis, their credit hour loads fall below that which is considered half time.
Thesis78b.W354.pdf
10.37 MB
Adobe PDF
06b2e7d0c07629566aa177e0f8a9614d