A theory of the ignorant and risk-averse monopolist
The literature on behavior under uncertainty as it relates to the theory of the firm is reviewed and analyzed. In particular, it is shown that the literature lacks a realistic treatment of the manner in which the firm constructs its choice set. Further, it is demonstrated that previous models failed to identify an explicit measure of risk by which all choices are comparable and thus were unable to address directly and meaningfully the nature of the role that risk plays in the firm's decision process.
A model is then developed that addresses the aforementioned shortcomings in the literature. It is shown that through the specification of some innocuous axioms governing the firm's view of its choices, it is possible to establish, for any option in the firm's choice set, an equivalent two-profit probability model. The character of the model is such that risk is explicitly and clearly represented for each choice, and this feature enables all choices to be risk comparable. The two-profit probability characterization when used in conjunction with the notion of a linear expected demand curve yields a convenient representation of choices as points on the expected demand curve. The important behavioral assumption that risk is greater or smaller to the extent that a choice is covered by the firm's recent experience is then given natural expression in terms of the Euclidean distance of choices from points of recent experience.
It is shown that the risk-averse monopolist will typically choose a price that is intermediate between the certainty price (the price associated with maximum expected profit) and the price associated with its relevant point of experience. The uncertainty point, therefore, will be higher or lower than the certainty price when the relevant experience point is higher or lower than the uncertainty price. When risk is present and changing across the choice set, the firm will set price at the certainty price if and only if the certainty price coincides with the price at the experience point. It is also shown that under uncertainty a change in fixed costs will affect the price set by the firm. The influences giving rise to this result are clearly identified. This result, of course, contrasts with the certainty result. In cases where the increase in risk resulting from the increase in fixed costs overpowers the accompanying increase in the marginal utility of profit, the firm will set price closer to the experience point. On the other hand, if the marginal utility increase overpowers the risk increase, then price will be set closer to the expected profit maximum price. An examination of the difference in the behavior of the quantity setter and the price setter is conducted, and the influences responsible for the asymmetry in their decisions are clearly identified, In some cases the quantity setter will perceive the greater risk and thus choose a point closer to the experience point than the price setter, and in other cases the price setter will perceive the greater risk and thus choose a point closer to the experience point. The definitive nature of the above results contrasts sharply with the indeterminant character of the results previously obtained in the literature.
Thesis78b.R454.pdf
3.67 MB
Adobe PDF
9bdce91712a9f0da61e43ad91485fd90