A study of the effects of self-modeling techniques by videotape feedback upon the acquisition of counseling skills by counselor trainees
This study was developed to measure the effectiveness of three self-modeling techniques on the learning of three counseling skills: (1) use of probes, (2) reflection of affect, and (3) focus on client. The three treatment groups were: (1) self-modeling by videotape to unedited, random counseling behaviors, (2) self-modeling by an edited videotape to appropriate counseling behaviors, and (3) self-modeling by videotape to appropriate counselor behaviors from prepared scripts.
Fifteen subjects from counseling practicums were assigned randomly to one of three treatment groups. Each subject in Groups 1 and 2 conducted four videotaped interviews with a client coached to emit specific cues. Each subject in Group 3 conducted a first and fourth taped interview with a coached client but conducted their second and third interviews using a prepared script filled with client cues and appropriate counselor responses.
Prior to an interview each subject viewed a different type of self-modeling from their previous interview. Each subject in Treatment Group 1 viewed a 10-minute randomly selected segment of unedited behaviors. Each subject in Group 2 observed a 10-minute edited self-modeling segment. The self-modeling content for Group 3 was segments from those interviews conducted with prepared scripts.
Trained raters compiled a frequency count of the dependent variables and additional counselor and client behaviors on the first (pretreatment) and fourth (posttreatment) tapes. These were converted to mean ratio scores by a client cue to counselor response observation system which could then be converted to percentages for both individual data and pooled data. The null hypotheses of no difference between the three treatment groups in terms of gain scores on each dependent variable was tested with the Kruskal-Wallis One-Way Analysis of Variance.
Results showed a significant difference (p < .01) between the groups scores on the variable of affect reflections. A Mann-Whitney U test revealed these differences to be between the random and scripts group (p < .004) and between the random and edited groups (p < .016). The Kruskal-Wallis yielded nonsignificant results across the treatment groups for the variables of focus on client and probes at the .05 level of significance. However, significant results were obtained at the .10 level of significance. The Mann-Whitney U Test on these variables showed a significant difference between the random and scripts groups on focus on client (p < .016) and on probes (p < .028). Further, the raw data revealed that the scripts group increased their scores more than the edited group. Since the scripts method was superior in absolute terms and easier to implement, it was concluded that among the approaches investigated in this study the scripts method is the most expedient means of training counselors.
Thesis78b.V352.pdf
2.72 MB
Adobe PDF
7cd91d977be86844b357956384ab6b2f