An analysis of perceived and expected roles of physical therapists
This field study explored relationships of the perceived (does) and the ideal (should) roles of the physical therapist as perceived by physicians, hospital administrators and physical therapist (PTs). The thrust of the study was to explore whatever conflicts might exist between bureaucratic and professional roles which physical therapists assume. Four null hypotheses postulated that there were no differences between and among respondent groups in their perceptions of and expectations for the physical therapist as expressed by responses to 74 questions, each with a does and a should component. These 74 questions were grouped into five clusters each representing some activity of the physical therapist.
The perceptions of (does) and expectations for (should) physical therapists' roles were obtained from 153 respondents from Texas by a questionnaire developed for this study. Respondent groups included physicians (N=33), hospital administrators (N=45), chief (N=43) and staff (N=32) physical therapists.
The questionnaire was field tested by 64 senior physical therapy students. Instrument, as well as cluster, reliability coefficients were computed. Instrument reliability, using the split-half method, was estimated at above .95 and cluster reliability ranged from .50 to .96 with eight of ten ranging from .83 to .96. Clusters of items as well as single items were used in analysis. Chi-square procedures were used for analysis of single items. A degree of consensus analysis was done for each single item which indicated significant differences. After respondent "scores" were generated for items and mean cluster computed, t-tests were utilized to analyze cluster differences, and differences between the does and should dimensions on the clusters.
Data supported the rejection of each general null hypothesis, indicating that there were differences in the respondent groups as to the role(s) of the physical therapist.
Smaller numbers of differences were found between hospital administrators and chief PTs may be more "bureaucratic" and more like hospital administrators in their perceptions of health care than are physicians and Pts.) The study indicated that the groups with the largest differences were physicians and chief physical therapists. Physicians and staff physical therapists had a relatively low number of differences.
Since role conflict does exist in the professional and bureaucratic roles of physical therapists, then less than optimal utilization of physical therapists occurs in our health-care system. Poor utilization and differences in perceived role have been postulated as a possible cause for turnover in allied health personnel. This study indicates that role conflicts do occur, and that these can be classified as professional-bureaucratic and professional-professional conflicts.
Thesis78b.P388.pdf
5.63 MB
Adobe PDF
51938a7d888a8cf2c13bfc22e4c92f61