A comparative study of the effects of required homework or quizzes on achievement in an undergraduate mathematics service course
The purpose of this investigation was to compare and evaluate student progress while using three different methods of teaching. The study was performed in the spring, 1978 semester at Liberty Baptist College in Lynchburg, Virginia. The course in which the study took place was Mathematics 103, Applications of Fundamental Mathematics, an undergraduate mathematics service course for students who are not majoring in mathematics or science. Three sections of the course were used in the study. Each section received a different treatment as a group. The groups and treatments were:
1. Compulsory Homework Group--students did compulsory homework which was graded and recorded.
2. Quiz Group--students took daily quizzes and did homework on a voluntary basis. Homework was not graded.
3. Control Group--students did voluntary homework which was not graded and did not take daily quizzes.
All students were taught by the experimenter at the same rate and were administered the same 4 unit examinations in the course of the 11 week study.
One hundred fourteen students began the experiment and 96 completed it. Students were compared at the outset of the study by application of an analysis of variance on their pretest and ACT mathematics scores. Another analysis of variance compared the groups in the middle of the study on a unit test and at the conclusion by a posttest. A short questionnaire at the termination of the study allowed for student feedback.
At the .05 level of significance no significant differences among the groups were found at the beginning of the study where mathematical background was the criterion being measured. Furthermore, at the .05 level, no significant differences in performance were found among the groups at the termination of the study. The questionnaire indicated that most of the students preferred homework as part of their mode of study.
Thesis78b.M388.pdf
3.32 MB
Adobe PDF
9737b78e53d76c6cfe1c6f47f940ab4d