Resilient Erosion and Sediment Controls - An Analysis of State DOT Practices
Date Issued
May 1, 2026
Author(s)
O'Hagan, Emma Lorin
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Jarrell Whitman
Additional Advisor(s)
Daniel Yoder
John Buchanan
Abstract
This study aimed to understand through a state-of-the-practice survey how state Departments of Transportation (DOTs) incorporate risk and resilience into erosion and sediment control (ESC) planning, design, and implementation. Risk is defined as the potential for an unwanted outcome resulting from an incident, event, or occurrence, as determined by its likelihood and associated consequences, while resiliency refers to the ability to prepare and plan for, absorb, recover from, or more successfully adapt to adverse events. The online survey was developed and distributed to state DOT stormwater professionals in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, and received 41 complete responses, representing an 80% response rate. The survey aimed to identify, document, and summarize practices and technologies used by state DOTs for resiliency-based selection and design of ESC practices used during highway construction. Key survey topics included commonly used ESC practices, observed vulnerabilities, site-specific factors influencing resilient designs, and the benefits and challenges of implementing resilient- and risk-based ESC strategies. Survey results indicate that of the responding state DOTs, 11 incorporate risk and resilience into ESC and Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plans (SWPPP), 24 only incorporate risk, and six do not incorporate either. The survey identified commonly specified ESC practices, and data on key design and operational factors pertaining to resiliency-based design methodologies. In addition to the survey, case example interviews were conducted with four state DOTs (Colorado, Georgia, Nebraska, and Tennessee) to gain deeper understanding of how risk and resilience is incorporated into ESC planning. Key findings from the interviews indicate that there is consistent integration of risk, varied approaches to resilience, and a shared focus on field adaptability, contractor input, and improving training and oversight. Based on the survey results and case example interviews, this study identified key considerations for incorporating risk and resilience into state DOT stormwater management programs. Additionally, a versatility index was created to evaluate ESC practices across usage, durability, and resilience dimensions, revealing that no single practice consistently performs well across all categories. These findings highlight the need for adaptive, performance-based design frameworks and standardized evaluation criteria to improve ESC reliability under increasing climate variability.
Degree
Master of Science
Major
Biosystems Engineering
Embargo Date
May 1, 2029