"THE ARCHIVES ARE THE BEATING HEART”: IMPOSED UTOPIA AND ARCHIVAL RESISTANCE IN THE PORTRAYAL OF WHITE CHRISTIAN NATIONALIST REGIMES IN MARGARET ATWOOD’S GILEAD AND OCTAVIA BUTLER’S EARTHSEED
Date Issued
May 1, 2026
Author(s)
Lay, Elliott Robert Matthias
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Dionte Harris
Additional Advisor(s)
Dawn Coleman
Bill Hardwig
Abstract
In Margaret Atwood’s Gilead duology and Octavia Butler’s Earthseed duology, both authors imagine a speculative future America where a particularly Christian vision of fascism reigns. Atwood’s and Butler’s work represent a shared prescience for the impact of evangelical Christian extremism that has been culturing in the United States since the Civil Rights era. This thesis combines contemporary sociological research into White Christian Nationalism in the United States with literary critique to analyze the intersection of Atwood’s and Butler’s portrayals of Christian fascist regimes and the resistance work writing such as their own effectuates. It uses Jacques Derrida’s theory of the archive to argue that archival work, particularly historiography and popular media, is a central tool in enacting an imposed, exclusionary Christian “utopia.” Conversely, this thesis also argues that counter archival work, work that records and preserves stories that transgress the state sanctioned archives, is necessarily central to implementing effective resistance to White Christian Nationalist regimes. Lastly, this thesis concludes that Atwood’s theory of “ustopia” is a sustainable and inclusive counter-vision of a just society to the imposed utopia of White Christian Nationalism, and that the transmission and expansion of counter archival work foster resistant community through generations that can promulgate and effectuate a ustopic vision and world.
Degree
Master of Arts
Major
Literature, Criticism, and Textual Studies
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
LAY-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
573.72 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
000a36c084f8373186edadcada958d72