Unheeded Advice Over Time: An Investigation into the Effects of Variations in Support Seeking Messages on Support Provision
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Devereux, Sarah E
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Jenny Crowley
Additional Advisor(s)
Jessica Frampton
Quinten Bernhold
Megan Haselschwerdt
Abstract
Supportive communication plays a critical role in coping with complex, enduring stressors, yet little is known about how advice interactions unfold across multiple episodes. Guided by Advice Response Theory logic, this dissertation examines how characteristics of a support seeking message influence the cognitive and affective responses of a provider over multiple time points. Specifically, this study experimentally tests the effects of the directness of a seeking request and justification to excuse non-implementation of previous advice. In so doing, this study simulated the phenomenon of unheeded advice, when a seeker repeatedly asks for advice about a stressor without implementing previously offered advice. Data was collected at two time points, with one week between collection. Participants read a hypothetical seeking message and imagined it came from a close friend before providing advice and assessing a provider’s motivation to provide support, feelings of sympathy for a seeker, and perceptions of advice quality. The hypothetical messages manipulated three patterns of support seeking over time: consistently direct (i.e., direct requests at T1 and T2), consistently indirect (i.e., indirect requests at T1 and T2), and increasingly direct (i.e., indirect at T1 and direct at T2) as well as two types of justifications: incriminating (i.e., making no effort to solve), and exonerating (i.e., making some effort to resolve). Direct strategies at T1 elicited greater feelings of sympathy compared to indirect strategies. At T2, directness nor justification alone significantly influenced outcomes. However, analyses indicated an interaction effect emerged between directness and justification, suggesting the effect of justification depended on the directness of the message. Incriminating justifications elicited the greatest sympathy when coupled with consistently indirect seeking requests, whereas exonerating justifications elicited the greatest sympathy when coupled with consistently or increasingly direct requests. Results extend understanding of supportive interactions over time and relevant message characteristics in repeated seeking interactions. Results provide avenues for future research and practical recommendations for seekers and providers to consider when dealing with complex and enduring stressors.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Communication and Information
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
DEVEREUX-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
943.41 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
d1bdfa6528a6f8c7da368ce242ba7310