PARENT–YOUTH DISCREPANT REPORTS OF PARENTING: PREDICTORS AND ASSOCIATIONS WITH YOUTH INTERNALIZED OUTCOMES
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Curtis, Shailey Ann
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Heidi Stolz
Additional Advisor(s)
Julia Yan
Elizabeth I. Johnson
Louis Rocconi
Abstract
This dissertation conceptualized and investigated relations of parent and youth discrepant reports of parenting with youth internalized outcomes. The first chapter laid the foundation by discussing the benefits of a multiple-informant approach to studying parenting, the theories and methods researchers have used to consider and explore parent and youth discrepant reports of parenting, and potential avenues for empirical work. The following two chapters are empirical investigations using data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development – Social Development Sub-study. The second chapter explored whether parent–youth discrepant reports of parenting are related to youth anxiety. Results using hierarchical regression indicated that including both parent and youth reports of parenting best predicted youth anxiety, however evidence was mixed for the predictive value of parent–youth discrepant reports of parenting and youth anxiety. Regarding patterns of discrepancy and youth anxiety, results using polynomial regression with response surface analysis indicated youth who agreed with their parent or reported higher than their parent on positive dimensions of parenting, namely parental involvement and positive parenting, reported less anxiety. For negative parenting dimensions, youth who reported similar amounts or higher than their parent on inconsistent discipline or poor monitoring/supervision reported more anxiety. Finally, youth from dyads where parents and youth both reported high or low amounts of parental poor monitoring/supervision reported more anxiety than parents and youth who share agreement at moderate levels of poor monitoring/supervision. The third chapter explored predictors of parent–youth discrepant reports of parenting. Using latent difference score modeling, results indicated that compared to parent reports, girls overreported positive parenting dimensions more than boys, and girls underreported negative parenting dimensions more than boys. Economic hardship was associated with youth reporting more negative parenting than their parents. Youth endorsing family obligation values associated with them reporting more positive dimensions of parenting than their parents. Parents’ endorsement of independence and self-reliance values associated with parents reporting more parental involvement, more positive parenting, and less maladaptive monitoring/supervision than their youth. Overall, this dissertation found that certain characteristics/contexts relate to parent–youth disagreements on parenting, and those disagreements are related to youth anxiety.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Human Development and Family Science
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
CURTIS-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
1.26 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
3d0c1c00d3815ca018a184fa49b163f4