Understanding Faculty Readiness for AI Integration in Higher Education: A Mixed-Methods Investigation of Knowledge, Attitudes, And Perspectives
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Amoako, Richard Dickson
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Jennifer Ann Morrow
Additional Advisor(s)
Louis M. Rocconi
Joshua Rosenberg
Austin Boyd
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) holds significant transformative potential for higher education. Educator readiness plays a vital role in successful adoption and integration, yet existing measurement methods do not fully capture this multidimensional construct. This mixed-methods study addresses critical gaps in understanding how faculty perceive, engage with, and integrate AI into teaching practices. The research comprises three interconnected studies. First, a systematic review of 19 empirical studies (2015–2025) revealed theoretical fragmentation in the literature, with dominant frameworks (TAM, UTAUT) failing to capture AI-specific pedagogical and institutional contexts. Second, a survey of U.S. faculty (N = 145), developed and validated through exploratory factor analysis, yielded three reliable factors: Integration and Effectiveness (α = .95), Institutional Support (α = .84), and Anxiety (α = .85). Third, qualitative inquiry with 15 faculty members across the U.S. uncovered nuanced perspectives, framing AI as a "pedagogical co-designer" rather than a mere tool, alongside profound concerns about cognitive offloading and institutional neglect. Triangulation across studies generated meta-inferences: (1) readiness depends more on pedagogical epistemology than on demographic variables; (2) anxiety often reflects ethical vigilance rather than resistance; and (3) institutional support must shift from tool provisioning to relational infrastructure that enables pedagogical experimentation. These insights led to the Faculty-Centered AI Integration Model (FCAIM), which reconceptualizes integration as value-laden negotiation rather than rational adoption. The study contributes a validated instrument for institutional assessment, advances theory beyond techno-deterministic frameworks, and offers evidence-based guidance for supporting human-centered AI integration that honors faculty agency and pedagogical autonomy.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Evaluation, Statistics, and Methodology
Embargo Date
May 1, 2029