The Contextualization of Student-Athlete Identity Development
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Shelton, Brent
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Pamela Angelle
Additional Advisor(s)
Misty Bailey
Mary Duenas
Rachel White
Abstract
Developing an identity is a complex and multidimensional journey that evolves through social interactions, relationships, and institutions as individuals explore and choose among meaningful occupational and ideological beliefs and opinions (Erikson, 1963; Marcia, 1966). For student-athletes, athletic participation plays a significant role in shaping identity development. While student-athlete identity development has drawn the interest of numerous scholars, additional investigations are needed to better understand the impacts of athletic participation from the vantage point of student-athletes. Therefore, in this study, I investigated the perceptions of National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I football student-athletes at Southeastern University regarding the ways in which athletic participation impacts their identity. Through thematic analysis of coded data generated from semi-structured interviews and online documents, I identified five domains of the participants’ identities in which athletic participation has significantly impacted. These included their athletic identity, moral identity, relational identity, developmental identity, and social prestige identity. Interpreting the findings of this study through the lens of Social Identity Theory, athletic participation appeared to impact the participants’ identity by uniquely shaping contextually relevant norms, values, and behavioral expectations that guided them through the processes of social categorization, identification, and comparison. Therefore, rather than functioning as a dominant organizing structure, athletic participation appeared to uniquely shape the process of identity development through specific social contexts. Taken together, the findings of this study led to the conceptualization of a Contextualized Model of Identity Development, which considers identity development as a differentiated process that is shaped by contextual conditions. The implications of this study suggested that higher education administrators approach student-athletes through holistic approaches that focus on reinforcing meaningful norms, values, and behaviors across multiple identity domains rather than targeting athletic participation or academic outcomes as isolated concerns. Additionally, implications highlighted the significant role that athletic coaching staff plays in guiding and preparing student-athletes for a life beyond sports participation.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Higher Education Administration
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
SHELTON-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
956.63 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
03f89917665b9d837374e381bc56273a