Modeling Security Vulnerability Determinants in the Siting of Advanced and Small Modular Nuclear Reactors: A Strategic Framework for Risk-Informed Decision-Making
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Adeniyi, Abiodun Idowu
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Srijib Mukherjee
Fangxing Li
Additional Advisor(s)
Howard Hall
Jamie Coble
Olufemi Omitaomu
Abstract
The deployment of Advanced and Small Modular Nuclear Reactors (A/SMRs) introduces unique security challenges due to their potential siting closer to population centers and in locations unsuitable for traditional large reactors. These security challenges necessitate enhanced security considerations during facility siting. However, existing siting frameworks prioritize safety over security, often delaying security assessments until the operational phase. This dissertation developed the Reactor Impact, Siting, and Security Evaluation (RISSE) framework to address this critical gap by integrating security vulnerability assessments into early-stage A/SMR siting decisions. Building on the OR-SAGE safety-focused framework, RISSE employs Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MDCA) within a Geographic Information System (GIS) environment to systematically evaluate site-specific features that could affect physical protection measures.
The framework incorporates three criteria weight generation methods—Equal Weight (EW), Subject Matter Expert (SME) Survey, and Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)—to assess Security Vulnerability Risk (SVR) across multiple indicators, including population proximity, protected areas, water sources, transportation networks, terrain characteristics, and emergency responder access. The framework was validated through a case study in a nuclear-emerging country evaluating A/SMR deployment sites, revealed a critical gap between safety and security assessments. While safety screening identified 32.45% of land area (4,269 sites) as suitable, subsequent security vulnerability analysis showed 89-93% of sites rated at medium-or-higher risk across three weighting methods, considering population proximity, protected areas, transportation networks, and emergency access.
This discrepancy highlights the necessity of integrating security considerations with safety assessments during site selection. Sensitivity analysis also demonstrated that site vulnerability risk is dependent on the security parameter weights, with the SME weighting method producing the most aggressive risk assessment (309 sites classified as 'Very High' risk), followed by EW (173 sites) and AHP (104 sites).
The RISSE framework enables proactive identification of security vulnerabilities during early siting, facilitating integration of cost-effective security measures into facility design and preventing significant construction delays and retrofitting costs. This research provides nuclear power stakeholders worldwide, particularly in nuclear-emerging countries, with a validated strategic tool for risk-informed decision-making in A/SMR facility siting.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Energy Science and Engineering
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
ADENIYI-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
3.83 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
571d504d536146fee6ec30b805d5c5ab