CRANIOFACIAL GROWTH PATERNS ACROSS POSTNATAL ONTOGENY
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Kilroy, Grace
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Dawnie Steadman
Additional Advisor(s)
Benjamin Auerbach
Valerie DeLeon
Abstract
The human craniofacial complex undergoes fundamental reorganization throughout postnatal development, yet how covariation patterns between cranial modules shift from infancy through adolescence remains largely unmapped. This dissertation addresses that gap by examining morphological covariation using CT scans of 79 individuals aged 0–20 years from the Subadult Virtual Anthropology Database. Individuals were assigned to three developmental cohorts—Infancy (0–1 years), Intermediate (1–16 years), and Young Adulthood (16–20 years)—under both chronological and dental age schemes to capture biologically meaningful developmental stages. Three-dimensional coordinates from 70 bilaterally symmetrized cranial landmarks were analyzed using Generalized Procrustes Analysis, Euclidean Distance Matrix Analysis, two-block Partial Least Squares, eigenvalue variance analysis, and centroid distance analysis to quantify directional dimensional differences, modular integration, and between-module covariation.
Craniofacial form and covariation differed substantially across cohorts. Vertical dimensions showed the largest between-cohort differences in the Infancy-to-Intermediate transition—posterior facial height differed by 102.1% there and 135.1% cumulatively from Infancy to Young Adulthood—while transverse dimensions, notably bigonial width, continued differentiating into Young Adulthood. Form Difference Matrices showed the mandible exhibited the greatest proportional dimensional differences of any module (FDM ≈ 1.800, ~80.0% increase in median interlandmark distance), and corpus–ramus covariation weakened progressively from r-PLS ≈ 0.978 in Infancy to ≈ 0.817 in Young
v
Adulthood, consistent with progressive functional differentiation accompanying dental eruption and masticatory development. The Infancy cohort showed uniformly strong covariation across all module pairs (r-PLS ≥ ~0.82), whereas by Young Adulthood a markedly more differentiated pattern emerged: basicranium–midface and midface–orbit covariation remained strong, but mandible-related covariation showed the most pronounced attenuation. These findings align with the developmental palimpsest framework, in which early neurally-driven development is progressively differentiated by later region-specific processes without being entirely overwritten.
The sample was deliberately restricted to individuals whose families provided documented consent for research use, aligning with emerging disciplinary standards that research involving human remains necessitates respect for families and descendant communities. This dissertation contributes to a comprehensive developmental framework for understanding craniofacial covariation while modeling ethical research practices consistent with the trajectory of professional values in biological anthropology.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Anthropology
Embargo Date
May 1, 2029