Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Doctoral Dissertations
  5. From Performative Gestures to Transformative Practice: Reimaging Allyship in Orchestral Music Education from a Social Work Perspective
Details

From Performative Gestures to Transformative Practice: Reimaging Allyship in Orchestral Music Education from a Social Work Perspective

Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Garrett, Kenyette  
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Javonda Williams-Moss
Andrea Joseph-McCatty
Additional Advisor(s)
C. Douglas Coatsworth
Juliet Hess
Kate McClernon-Chaffin
Midori Sampson
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/57682
Abstract
From Performative Gestures to Transformative Practice examines racial allyship as a developmental, relational, and systemically situated practice across educational and artistic contexts. Paper One is a scoping review that synthesizes U.S.-based, peer‑reviewed literature (2020–2024) on allyship for K–12 music education, guided by a synthesized framework integrating Critical Social Work (Gates et al., 2023) and Authentic Allyship (Pietri et al., 2024). The review identifies four cross-cutting themes—Awareness & Reflexivity, Collaborative Praxis, Accountability, and Institutional Advocacy—and maps uneven coverage across the field, with institutional advocacy most developed and reflexivity/accountability comparatively under-specified. This analysis clarifies where the literature advances beyond performative gestures and where concrete, practice-ready guidance is still lacking. Paper Two investigates how allyship is perceived and enacted within a predominantly white institution (PWI) using Constructivist Grounded Theory and a theoretical framing that combines Intersectionality with Generational Theory. Across cohorts, Baby Boomers tended to frame allyship as moral duty, Gen X as pragmatic and risk‑calibrated, Millennials as relational accountability and intra‑group education, and Gen Z as reflexive, identity‑attuned, and historically grounded. These cohorted orientations were further refracted by role (student, staff, faculty) and by structural positioning (beneficiaries of systemic racism vs. groups marginalized by systemic racism), revealing how lived histories, family socialization, material security, and institutional status shape what “counts” as allyship and who bears risk. Paper Three uses Ecological Systems Theory and Critical Race Theory to examine how Black orchestral musicians experienced allyship from their non‑Black K–12 music educators, with particular attention to the protective factors that either insulated them from racial harm or intensified the need for allyship. Across participants, protective factors such as strong parental advocacy, early exposure to music instruction, access to private lessons, or culturally responsive mentors functioned as buffers against the racialized barriers embedded in orchestral education. When these protective factors were present, participants often reported fewer direct experiences of racial hostility, which in turn shaped their perceptions of allyship—they needed it less to survive and more to thrive. Conversely, when protective factors were absent or inconsistent, allyship became a critical intervention, mediating access, retention, and belonging within predominantly white musical spaces. This paper demonstrates that allyship is perceived not only through educators’ behaviors but also through the ecological conditions surrounding the child; protective factors can obscure, lessen, or heighten the visibility and necessity of allyship. By centering the lived experiences of Black musicians, the study clarifies how allyship fills systemic gaps left when protective factors are missing—and how, in their presence, allyship must still be deliberate, relational, and culturally affirming to contribute meaningfully to sustained participation in orchestral ensembles.
Subjects

Social Work

Orchestral Music Educ...

Education, Music

Allyship

Black orchestral stud...

social work

inclusion

allyship

music education

Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Social Work
Embargo Date
May 1, 2029

University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science